Baseball Vs. Football Essay, Research Paper

Baseball vs. Football: Which Is The True American Pastime?

In today & # 8217 ; s universe of large clip professional athleticss there are the two major participants and they are football represented by the National Football League ( NFL ) and baseball represented by Major League Baseball ( MLB ) . Now there are other athleticss that the American public enjoys observation, nevertheless the statement by and large boils down to which athletics is the true favourite of the American people: baseball or football. In this paper I will try to analyze both athleticss from several different angles to include attending, telecasting gross, ticket costs, locales, wages, amusement value, and athlete perceptual experience. The end of this exercising will be to find, one time and for all, which athletics is the American favourite and can genuinely be called the & # 8220 ; American Pastime & # 8221 ; .

One of the individual greatest mensurable aspects of professional athleticss is attending. A athletics & # 8217 ; s popularity is in direct correlativity to the figure of people that will demo up to watch that athletics. Overall 2000 habitue season attending in Major League Baseball was a record 72,782,013 in 2,416 games for an mean per game crowd of 30,125 whereas official overall paid attending in the National Football League for the 2000 season was 16,387,289 in 248 games for an mean per game crowd of 66,077. The mean per game crowd is the mensurable statistic due to the fact that the figure of games in a regular season for baseball and football are really different. A NFL squad plays a regular season agenda of 16 game nevertheless a MLB squad plays a regular season agenda of 162 games so mean attending per game presents an accurate image of popularity. Therefore, football appears to be more than twice every bit popular as baseball when measured by attending.

Ever since the debut of telecasting into American dad civilization professional athleticss organisation have looked to maximise this medium. Television gross is now large concern in athleticss today with telecasting webs paying big sums of money to procure the right to air clean events. The Super Bowl ( which is the title game in the NFL ) is systematically the highest rated broadcast every twelvemonth, which allows the lucky web to bear down iniquitous sums of money in advertisement. The NFL and MLB both enjoy big telecasting contracts although their gross sharing programs are rather different. The NFL presently receives 2.2 billion dollars a twelvemonth in telecasting gross, which amounts to 73 million per twelvemonth per squad. MLB presently receives 340 million dollars per twelvemonth in telecasting gross, which is divided up among the squads in a expression so complicated that you need understand quantum-physics and theoretical mathematics merely to derive a fundamental apprehension of the distribution construction. These Numberss are interesting in that there are less football squads to telecast which means that the NFL must earn obscene evaluations to demand that much money. Baseball games are on about every dark on a assortment of different channels and evaluations can be considered blue when placed in comparing to the NFL. I believe the chief ground for the evaluations difference is season length. The NFL season is so short and every game means so much that the play degree is much higher when compared to the day-to-day beat of 162 baseball games where losing one or two games a hebdomad is non considered black. If a NFL squad were to lose 5 games in a row opportunities are they would non do the playoffs nevertheless if a MLB squad loses 5 games in a row they may still win it all.

How much does it be to see a professional football or baseball game? Ticket monetary values vary but the mean ticket monetary value in 200 for a NFL competition was $ 54.14 with the highest mean ticket monetary value being $ 74.28 to see the Washington Redskins ( Washington, D.C. ) and the lowest mean ticket monetary value being $ 33.99 to see the St. Louis Rams ( St. Louis, MO ) . The mean ticket monetary value in 200 for a MLB competition $ 20.02 with the highest mean ticket monetary value being $ 28.33 to see the Boston Red Sox ( Boston, MA ) and the lowest mean ticket monetary value being $ 11.72 to see the Milwaukee Brewers ( Milwaukee, WI ) . Once once more the season length and game importance being the most of import factors in finding ticket monetary value. It is non realistic to anticipate a MLB squad to inquire for $ 75 a game over a 162 game season nevertheless the NFL can because of the short season length. These figures merely take into history the admittance monetary value and non the added costs of bites or refreshments, which can be astronomical. However, these figures suggest that the best value for today & # 8217 ; s American household would be to go to a baseball game.

Some say that the greatest portion about traveling to a baseball or football game is non the nutrient, the jocks, or the conditions, but instead the bowl itself. Today & # 8217 ; s professional athletics locales are more Disneyland than backyard and have become a gathering topographic point for households, friends, and colleagues. Many corporations now do serious concern in the luxury boxes at several bowls and unluckily the blue-collar presence that was everyplace 10 old ages ago seems to be vanishing at today & # 8217 ; s out-of-door events to be replaced by the white-collar crowd. I believe the best thing about a clean event is the crowd noise, which can be a consequence of shouting, booing, or merely excessively much intoxicant. However, there is nil better than experiencing a bowl rumble in your thorax. Crowd noise is dependent on bowl capacity and that is where baseball typically falls behind football. The mean MLB locale can keep around 47,000 people with bowls in San Diego puting the saloon high at 66,307. The smallest MLB locale can be found in Boston at Fenway Park, which holds 33,871, which is funny because as we learned above the Boston Red Sox besides have the highest mean ticket monetary value. The mean NFL locale can keep around 70,000 people with the largest bowl being the Detroit Silverdome, which can keep 80,311 people. The smallest NFL locale is located in Indianapolis and can keep 56,120 people. In add-on to herd noise the 2nd most of import characteristic about a NFL or MLB locale may be their historical value. Many baseball fans will state you the importance of topographic points such as Wrigley Field in Chicago or Fenway Park in Boston although the proprietors of those squads will state you that they need new and more modern locales. The oldest ballpark in the MLB is so Fenway Park in Boston and was built in 1912 and the oldest locale in the NFL is Soldier Field in Chicago and was built in 1924. I have visited both locales and will acknowledge that there is something particular about sitting in a bowl that was built 80 or 90 old ages ago and believing about all the great participants that have played at that place. I believe the grounds supports the statement that the NFL locales are genuinely larger and louder whereas MLB ballparks are known for their history.

Player wages are frequently claimed by squad proprietor to be the individual largest factor in the determination to raise ticket monetary values. Player wages are now so big that the American populace can non even do a comparing. The mean participant wage in MLB in 2000 was a small over two million per twelvemonth with Alex Rodriguez taking the battalion at $ 25,200,000 per twelvemonth.

The mean participant wage in the NFL in 2000 was 1.18 million dollars per twelvemonth. Baseball participants systematically make more money than their football opposite numbers due in big parts to the salary cap constructions in the several conferences. In the NFL each squad must field a 53-person roll while maintaining their wage under the 2001 salary cap of 67.4 million dollars, nevertheless in MLB there is no salary cap so participants can do every bit much as possible. There used to be a system of luxury taxing in MLB but that system expired in 2000 so there are presently no salary obstructions to participants in baseball. The luxury revenue enhancement system required the five baseball squads with the highest paysheets to pay a revenue enhancement that helped to maintain the playing field degree between big and little market squads. However, with no type of salary control in usage by MLB each participant can have as much money as an proprietor is willing to pay as evidenced by Alex Rodriguez’s immense wage. The NFL salary cap has been lauded as the exclusive ground that the NFL is so competitory and a different title-holder seems to emerge every twelvemonth, nevertheless in baseball the same squads are near the top every twelvemonth and it is no happenstance that the New York Northerners have won the World Series the last few old ages and they besides have the largest paysheet. A big market squad such as the Northerners can afford to overpay participants because they enjoy a bigger gate and larger telecasting grosss than a squad like the Montreal Expos. In the NFL all the money is disbursed every bit and the salary cap helps to maintain all squads competitory. Therefore, the conference with the highest participant wages is non needfully the conference that offers the most competitory merchandise. The lone lesson to be learned here is that if you have an athletically gifted kid you may desire to direct that kid towards baseball to maximise his/her payday.

Athlete perceptual experience in both athleticss plays a big portion in attending, telecasting gross, ticket costs, and several other countries within the NFL and MLB. Presently the participants in the NFL are regarded as the most unsafe and out of control jocks. The recent play affecting O.J. Simpson, Ray Carruth, and Ray Lewis hold given the NFL a serious black grade among the fans. While baseball participants are by and large seen as a greedy clump the football participant is now seen as a condemnable with small or no respect for the jurisprudence. Domestic force has now unluckily become portion of the NFL and MLB mainstream with several incidents documented in both conferences each twelvemonth, yet the fans do non even seem to care about these incidents but instead focal point on the more theatric, more serious, and more rare serious offenses. There are 100s upon 100s of domestic force instances each twelvemonth but merely one knifing outside an Atlanta cabaret affecting Ray Lewis. Guess which one the populace remembers? The NFL and MLB have taken several stairss to better their images with advertisement, run into the participant runs, and community service and lone clip will state if these efforts work but I believe for all the good that these participants do and for all the positive promotion that these participants may garner it will merely take one participant to destroy it all for that is the true nature of being a famous person. Based upon the above information I believe that MLB participants are presently seen in a better visible radiation than NFL participants and as more favourable function theoretical accounts although they may be perceived as greedy.

Entertainment value is difficult to mensurate since there is no manner to cognize for certain what people like to see. Obviously fans of one athletics will claim their athletics offers the best merchandise. Both the NFL and MLB put a solid merchandise on the field that is good accompanied, comparatively low-cost, and merriment to watch. Therefore, it is my sentiment that both athleticss offer equal amusement value and neither should be condemned on this factor. Both athleticss are so different that comparing their amusement value would be unjust. As a witness of both athleticss I am happy to describe that I feel that both athleticss did an equal occupation in carry throughing my amusement demands.

I have examined both baseball and football from several different point of views and it my belief that football is genuinely the American interest. Football enjoys larger mean attending, sensible tickets costs given the season length, sensible participant wages when compared to baseball, better overall locales, and football provides a thrilling and exciting merchandise to watch. Football destroys baseball in telecasting evaluations and telecasting gross by demanding and acquiring telecasting contracts that baseball can merely woolgather approximately. And what is a better benchmark for popularity so telecasting evaluations? Plus football & # 8217 ; s title game, the Super Bowl, is portion of pop civilization in that practically everyone throws or attends a Super Bowl party each twelvemonth. The Super Bowl is the highest rated broadcast on web telecasting each twelvemonth and serves as a assemblage event for friends and households. Some companies even give their employees the following twenty-four hours off, which means that the Super Bowl is practically on par with a national vacation. None of these things happen for baseball. While it is true that football does acquire a black grade in athlete perceptual experience I believe that it more than makes up for that in the other countries and while baseball is a comparatively cheap medium for household assemblages the baseball games merely don & # 8217 ; t carry as much importance as football. Therefore, I believe my statements back up my decision that football is the true American interest and on a separate non I can non wait for September and the first kickoff of a new season!

Bouchette, Ed ( 1998 ) . Steelers non awash with hard currency for bowl. Pittsburgh Post Gazette, 17 April 1998. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.post-gazette.com/planb/19980417QandA.asp

CNN Sports Illustrated ( 2000 ) . MLB Baseball: Average MLB salary doubles in eight old ages. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //sportsillustrated.cnn.com/baseball/mlb/news/2000/04/05/mlb_salaries_ap/

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . 1999 NFL Attendance. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0779227.html

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . Highest and Lowest Ticket Prices. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0875108.html

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . Home Attendance. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0877026.html

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . Major League Baseball Ballparks. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0105512.html

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . National Football League Stadiums. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0105600.html

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . Rank by Capacity. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0105519.html

Infoplease.com ( 2000 ) . Top 10 Salaries in Each Sport. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.infoplease.com/ipsa/A0875101.html

NFL.com ( 2001 ) . NFL sets all clip attending record. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.nfl.com/news/010326attendance.html

Poole, David ( 1999 ) . Nascar confirms it will negociate Television trades. The Charlotte Observer, 24 February 1999. Retrieved July 15, 2001 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.thatsracin.com/99/docs/0225nascartv.htm