Impact of Gender Difference on Teamwork Essay Sample

Free Articles

Introduction
Male childs or girls- Who are better or smarter? This is a good known world-wide phenomena and contention when it comes to gender that is better in comparing since the beginning of the creative activity. Many arguments and researches have under taken to reply this inquiry but in terminal no 1 can reason this. When it comes to competition the enthusiasm of winning is its extremum in both genders. This survey is based upon a existent attempt experiment to prove “The Impact of gender differences on teamwork” . The chief thought behind carry oning the experiment is to happen out that who can execute better in teamwork male childs or misss. We studied the competition between the squads and where the squad with the highest public presentation will win the gift shackle. Background of survey:

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

? Defining teamwork Teamwork is defined in Webster’s New World Dictionary as “a joint action by a group of people. in which each individual subordinates his or her single involvements and sentiments to the integrity and efficiency of the group. ” Coming together is a beginning. Keeping together is advancement. Working together is success. ~Henry Ford The importance of teamwork is increasing globally because it increases the productiveness and enhances the collaborative acquisition. When planing the experiment we were of the position that boys better execute as a squad and they are more efficient in executing undertakings like to happen the hints and work outing such intelligence based intimations as comparison to misss. Although the public presentation of male childs and misss squad besides depends on the type of undertaking given to them and there are many other factors that are physical. intelligence. and some environmental factors besides behind their success. ? Reasons to take the experiment type We choose the game for happening the hints to prove teamwork because of no. of ground. First this activity requires the full concentration and it is easy to look into the coordination between the squad members every bit good. Second for executing this undertaking each member had to set the existent attempts because they were supposed to work out the hint at the topographic point and in short span. Furthermore it becomes easy to us to mensurate the end product precisely without any biasness.

? Introduction to experiment The experiment is conducted in Bahria university Karachi campus in a schoolroom environment. For the experiment. squads dwelling merely of male childs and squads dwelling merely of misss were formed. The squads are required to happen out the different hidden hints in a category room in a short span of clip as comparison to their oppositions to win the game and their public presentation is measured on the footing of timing and observation that although everyone is seting attempt every bit or non and their coordination in a squad. Related research: A research is conducted on Gender Differences in Team Work and Team Competition by Radosveta Ivanova-Stenzel and Dorothea Kubler to look into the relevancy of gender for the optimum composing of a squad and whether the composing of a squad affects the public presentation under different inducement strategies. For the experiment. squads dwelling merely of work forces. squads dwelling merely of adult females and assorted squads dwelling of work forces and adult females are formed.

So in order to prove this participants had to work out the memory based games in a short span of clip which is 15mins. there were two inducements for them one is team competition and second is gross sharing. The consequences shows that work forces solve more games than adult females therefore we can state that the gender affects the public presentation of squad and public presentation is dependent on the squad composing. While the incentive strategy does non impact the single public presentation nevertheless it is really the competition between the squads that affect their public presentation. Hypothesis: A no of surveies have conducted in different Fieldss to measure the gender differences and their behaviour. cooperation. fight between them every bit good as executing the intelligence and memory based undertakings. This survey explores the issue that how male childs can break execute in a squad and why misss can non execute better in such type of games and old researches besides showed that boys execute better so we design the experiment to look into the grounds and chief factors behind this issue. Our position is based on the personal experience and every bit good as on the old surveies. So we postulate the undermentioned hypothesis of the above stated experiment is:

H1: Performance of Boys As a Team Is Exceling As Compared To Girls. Aim: The aims of this research survey are as follows: ? ? ? Evaluate the Gender Differences in Team Work and Team Competition To set about the primary research on male childs & A ; misss at Bahria University in order to analyze the consequence of the gender differences on their teamwork To reason the impact of gender in the successes of teamwork

LITERATURE REVIEW
Recent surveies find that adult females are less competitory than work forces. This gender difference in fight has been suggested as one possible account for why work forces occupy the bulk of top places in many sectors. Harmonizing to Schrage ( 1999 ) . the unconditioned differences of work forces and adult females are due to some factors ; those could be biological 1s. or there is a sort of fight between work forces and adult females. The public presentation of work forces and adult females should non be different if they both are every bit adept and wagess are same for both the groups. However. it is observed that work forces perform better than adult females. Differences in public presentation between adult females and work forces depend on the specific undertaking. Radosveta Ivanova-Stenzel and Dorothea Kubler ( 2005 ) conducted an experiment in which memory undertaking reveals a clear dissymmetry in that work forces solve on norm more games than adult females. Harmonizing to Canaray and Dindia ( 2006 ) Researchers typically report that work forces are more likely to look as leaders. to be directing and hierarchal. to rule in groups by speaking more and disrupting more. In contrast. adult females are found to be more expressive. sympathetic. facilitative. unfastened. and concerted than work forces. and to concentrate more on relationships and portion more personally with others.

From this account of the difference between work forces and adult females. it was clear that adult females convey their thoughts and feelings and collaborate more than work forces who want to be the leaders and to direct. In Nowell and Tinkler. s ( 1994 ) survey of public good games. all-female groups are somewhat more concerted than all-male groups and assorted groups. In Niederle and Vesterlund ( 2005 ) there is no difference between the public presentation of work forces and adult females in a competitory environment. but when given the pick. adult females prefer non to vie. Harmonizing to Radosveta Ivanova-Stenzel and Dorothea Kubler ( 2005 ) female and male public presentation vary most in assorted squads. as work forces put in notably more attempt than adult females. The information besides indicate out that adult females perform best when viing in pure female squads against male squads whereas work forces execute best when adult females are present or in a competitory environment. Harmonizing to Dr Andrew J. Martin ( 2002 ) There are gender differences in accomplishment. battle and motive. Many of these show that boys execute more ill than misss like in literacy. accomplishment. school completion. and motive. There are. nevertheless. countries in which male childs are non underperforming misss like in numeracy.

Harmonizing to ( Niederle and Vesterlund 2007 ) work forces compete more than what is best for them while adult females compete less and it has besides been observed that adult females tend to prefer the noncompetitive scene even when there is no gender spread in public presentation in the competitory scene. Harmonizing to Remy Melina ( September 2011 ) Outside of group scenarios. the research workers noted that some differences between work forces and adult females surfaced. Work force were found to be more concerted with other work forces than adult females were during same-gender interactions. When interacting with the opposite gender. adult females were more concerted than work forces. the analysis found. Beverly Keyes Taylor wrote in an article. for work forces. teamwork by and large means that each participant on the squad has specific endowments or things that they are good at and together as a squad they make up a whole. There by and large is no exchanging about from one place to another and each person’s responsibilities are specific and exact and that person/team participant can be counted on to make their specific responsibility to their best whereas for adult females. teamwork by and large means all the people/team participants portion all of the duties. Everyone normally works together on a more collaborative degree and things are by and large non as strict or stiff. Thingss by and large flow. and people work harmoniously. assisting one another and filling in wherever necessary.

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
From the above literature reappraisal we can reason that teamwork is the result of dedication. coordination and accomplishments and it is largely found in male childs as a squad. It differs from squad to team depending on its nature ; whether it is of same-gender or opposite-gender. Many research workers conducted experiments to look into the public presentation of male childs when working as a squad and at the same clip public presentation of misss in a squad. It is found in most of the related researches that male childs can execute better when working in a squad as comparison to girls’ squad. The ground which was mentioned as to why male childs surpass misss is that they are more dedicated. enthusiastic and coordinated than misss. But once more it depends on the nature of the undertaking which can drive the motive in an person to execute it expeditiously. Other variables besides affect the teamwork ; environment. nature of the undertaking and wagess. All-male squads were expected to execute more accurately than all-female squads. In general. all-male members performed more efficaciously than all-female squads on quantitative undertakings ( Wood. 1987 ) and are more undertaking oriented ( Jackson et al. 1995 ) . While adult females are associated with higher social/facilitative accomplishments. this undertaking does non necessitate understanding or dialogue. After reexamining the literature. we come up with the hypothesis that public presentation of male childs as a squad is exceling every bit compared to misss.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
In order to prove for gender and incentive effects in an appropriate environment. participants worked on a existent undertaking they had to work out assorted memory based intimations likewise the hoarded wealth Hunt. We prepared assorted hints for the participants in which conundrums were mentioned and they had to come up with the solution of it in order to make to their following hint and likewise five hints were given to the participants within the clip bounds assigned to each group based on the fact the 1 who performs in the shortest span of clip will be considered the victor of the game and will be rewarded. Each hint consists of a conundrum and each squad consists of 5 members but unfortunately misss were four which may hold affected their public presentation. As our hypothesis lies on the fact that male childs are more efficient in public presentation of undertakings in a squad due to their accomplishments. abilities and enthusiasm as comparison to the misss. what we assumed was right male childs were more efficaciously executing instead than misss. While carry oning this experiment we had to go through through assorted troubles. ? ? ? Firstly no handiness of suites Permission issues Finally when the set up was done category started so we failed to carry on it the really first clip

The 2nd clip we were able to carry on the experiment successfully. As the experiment began foremost the misss were given the opportunity to execute. they tried their degree best to acquire the reply to the inquiries that were mentioned in the signifier of hints but they lack a small spot of coordination and were non every bit much as active in comparing to the male childs. what they lack was a sense of corporation among them and seemed to a spot unenrgetic may be because we conducted the experiment after the categories got over or may be due to any other ground. Another trouble which we faced during choice of misss squad was that since it was the off clip many misss left and so we had to name misss from other subdivision. May be this factor besides affected the misss public presentation because they were unknown to each other so they didn’t had that degree of corporation amongst them. Now comes the bend for the male childs they were really active during their public presentation and good coordinated.

They scattered in the room instantly to happen the hints and one by one rapidly they found all the hints they merely pass more clip on the last hint because they weren’t acquiring the intimation right but so one of the male childs identified that hint every bit good. As we are all cognizant of the fact that boys consists of more leading qualities than misss so they showed those factors which we expected from the male childs. Each member of the male childs squad were happening their best possible manner to happen the hint and they all were really dedicated towards their undertaking and a feeling of accomplishing success existed among them. The male childs proved themselves and completed their undertaking in less clip as comparison to the misss. Girls completed their undertaking in 14 mins where as the male childs in 7 mins approx so as our hypothesis proved to be true. Ultimately boys were the victors.

Consequence
This portion of the research survey includes treatments on the experiment in context of the literature reappraisal. These findings and analyses services evidences for replying the research inquiry and future recommendations. The findings of our research survey reveal that male childs are more rational in job in job resolution and prompt determinations. Several experiments have been conducted which resulted the same that male childs are quicker than misss in rational competitions like conundrums and mystifier resolution. Another empirical research by Radosveta Ivanova-Stenzel and Dorothea Kubler ( 2005 ) besides reveals that memory undertaking reveals a clear dissymmetry in that work forces solve on norm more games than adult females.

Our aim was to find the gender’s impact on squad. research survey shows that male childs are more elegant and enthusiastic in squads as they have general inclination to joint and execute good in groups and squads. They combine their different accomplishments to finish undertaking therefore they are more successful in work that are divided. Furthermore the quality of being dominant over others is somehow innate in male childs. They like to govern the game and demo prima behaviour over others to turn out their engagement and affirm to be the front man to acquire the maximal wages. This might be due to some natural factors. Harmonizing to Schrage ( 1999 ) . the unconditioned differences of work forces and adult females are due to some factors ; those could be biological 1s. or there is a sort of fight between work forces and adult females.

Decision
The concluding chapter of this research survey concludes the findings of the research and discourse about the attainment of purpose explained in the treatment of the research and how three set aims have been achieved to make the decision of the research. All three aims are elaborated in this decision under separate headers. The rating of the research is to project the inside informations about assorted things that have been dealt by the research worker while get downing research. This research experiment has its restriction as it is based on observation and high generalizability and the findings are merely limited to current experiment. This last portion can help other research workers to transport out research in more deepness. Objective 1: Measure the Gender Differences in Team Work and Team Competition There are assorted types of impacts that are predominating in the squad as identified by Carol ( 2009 ) as the research worker suggested out of 100 % of boys 75 % male childs have a strong motive to execute jointly whereas misss participants are more eager to work on single footing. In our research the consequences are bespeaking that gender has an huge function while representing or organizing multi-gender squads.

Furthermore. we have apparent that male childs are more vigorous and concerted in squads and has strong impulse to develop common trust and assurance hence in their several groups they are more equal and justly directed towards their several ends. Cooper and Marshall ( 1976 ) besides identified as the theory suggests that competency are nucleus in squad work and extremely rely on different types of gender’s reactivity. Harmonizing to Mike and Simpsons ( 2003 ) feminine and masculine public presentation differs particularly in squads that are constituted on assorted evidences. Our findings have besides considered both misss and male childs for this research as of import constituent to demo the brightest facet of gender based attitude on assorted evidences. Mike and Simpsons ( 2003 ) revealed that the information collected has the critical facet of work forces performs at a better degree than adult females and our findings are besides likewise to this. Though the findings of Radosveta are unlike our findings they have stressed on the portion that adult females are more dynamic as comparison to work forces in a squad but our findings strongly suggest that male childs are non inactive in squad work. Objective 2: To set about the primary research on male childs & A ; misss at Bahria University in order to analyze the consequence of the gender differences on their teamwork.

The primary research conducted at Bahria University in order to analyse the consequence of gender differences on their several public presentations in squad and we can reason on the footing of our primary findings that there is strong impact of gender differences on the existent public presentation of teamwork. In our research we have closely examined that male childs are more enthusiastic willing and competent and our findings are indistinguishable to Dr James J. Andrew ( 2001 ) There are gender differences in accomplishment. battle and motive. Many of these show that boys execute more jointly than misss like in plants that requires combine attempts whereas misss are more competent in literacy. accomplishment. school completion. and motive. Objective 3: To reason the impact of gender in the successes of teamwork To reason our research few of the supporting groundss are the old empirical researches of bookmans like Menzel. Leath and Folkman The theory of John and Menzel ( 1999 ) suggest that there are chiefly two types of gender found in squads and they have changing capacity of executing their undertaking peculiarly because of the physical constructions. educational backgrounds and different experiences. Male childs have shown more energy in undertaking that required physical operation and furthermore they are quicker in work outing conundrums and mystifiers.

The findings of Menzel are besides similar that work forces are more actively take parting in activities that require physical and mental abilities whereas adult females are non as quicker in work outing jobs as work forces in a group. The work of leath ( 2002 ) and our findings are similar that in a combine group of male childs and misss work forces are more ascendant as comparison to misss. Folkman ( 2004 ) has strongly argued that work forces are by nature ruling in groups whereas adult females are normally followings. We have besides to some extent found that work forces are more active and ruling in group activities. Though our findings suggest that male childs are more concerted and coordinate well in teamwork but this research is merely limited to the category room of Bahria University. the consequences may differ and change to some extent if conducted at another topographic point or the sample size of the population is either changed or increased.

Discussion
DISCUSSION BASED ON RESEARCH For this research both the squads of opposite genders were provided with a same undertaking to expose their squad efficiency. so that our hypothesis about male childs can break execute than misss can be proved or disproved. nevertheless both squads didn’t respond in a similar mode. there were quiet differences in their ways of accomplishing their undertakings. Following are the observations that were made. OBSERVATION PRIOR TO THE EXPERIMENT Following observations could be made before the experiment was started. Initial response The participants of both genders got to cognize that they were approximately to play a game merely before the game was approximately to acquire started. when this intelligence was revealed at that clip misss showed a small vacillation whereas the male childs got aroused and were wholly relaxed about whatever they were approximately to make. even when they didn’t knew what it was.

Hence the initial assurance of male child was better than misss. Disclosure of the game Both the squads were quiet excited when they got to cognize that the game they were approximately to play was an interesting game of happening the hints. squads of both genders were really much tidal bore to play that game. OBSERVATION DURING THE EXPERIMENT During the experiment when it was high clip for the participants to demo their squad work as it was instructed to them. following observations were found. Performance of both the squads The features that turn out to be productive in doing persons work like a squad includes good communicating. active engagement. committedness with the undertaking. squad members motivation degree. therefore these features were chiefly observed while participants were executing their undertaking. Following observations were made. Communication degree: We were anticipating that as this game was based on work outing the hints. some truly good communicating would be seen among the members of both the squads. but the resulting communicating degree was non so good from boy’s squad. every person was seeking to believe for the hints on its ain instead than discoursing with other squad members. However. the misss did demo some satisfactory communicating. still there were some weak points in their communicating as good.

Engagement: As it was a squad work based undertaking. every person was required to lend in accomplishing the end which was work outing hints and demo their presence in the squad. members from both squads did participated good but there were some points in clip when the enthusiasm of few participants was non up to the grade. Still for male childs it was better every bit compared to misss. in girls squad few of the participants did started actively but with clip their action had gone and they failed to do their presence felt. Commitment. It was clearly observed that male childs were more committed to their undertaking as compared to misss. male childs did set in more attempts to accomplish their coveted end every bit shortly as they can. Girls besides did demo committedness to their undertakings but their shyness made them lack behind. they were quiet hesitant at some points and even asked the experimenters for permission if they wanted to seek for a hint someplace. whereas boys didn’t bothered to inquire for permissions.

It was clearly observed that at that clip all that the male childs knew was that they have to complete the game every bit shortly as possible. Motivation degree. Both the squads were themselves motivated in finishing their undertakings as they knew that they will merely win if they managed to finish their undertaking before the squad of their opposite gender dosage. But particularly for misss the motive degree went down when they couldn’t manage to work out the hint Oklahoman and rose once more as they managed to eventually work out the hint. for misss this narrative continues with all hints. whereas for male childs. their motive degree was up throughout the game and it can be concluded that this was the ground that leaded them towards their success. OBSERVATIONS AFTER THE EXPERIMENT After the experiment. the victor squad was non instantly revealed. although both the squads showed their inquisitiveness in cognizing that who was really the victor. both the squads truly appreciated what they had done and even praised the research workers for their attempts. but here besides one thing was noticeable that even after the game had finished the motive degree of the male childs was far better than misss and even before cognizing the consequences they were really much confident about their success and even

Disclosure OF RESULTS When consequences were revealed and it was eventually declared that male childs have won the game which they were really confident about. a assorted feeling of joy. enthusiasm and exhilaration was observed from winner’s side which showed that non merely did they cognize how to play the game good but besides had the ability to observe their success. the victors sooner got overjoyed when they were rewarded with that most anticipated box of cocoas. However. misss on the other manus besides took their failure really sportingly and congratulated the winning squad wholeheartedly. yet a small letdown was at that place from the girl’s side which was but natural. DISCUSSION BASED RECOMMENDATIONS FOR BOTH THE GENDERS From the overall treatment it can be concluded that. male childs do posses all the qualities that turns out to do them more productive and high winners yet they need to better their communicating accomplishments to accomplish the coveted consequences in a better manner.

For misss. to accomplish their desired success they merely need to raise up their assurance degree and the other points which they lack behind in will automatically be raised DISCUSSION BASED ON RELATED RESEARCHES From literature reappraisal. the first research tells us that the innate differences of work forces and adult females are due to some factors such as fight between work forces and adult females and our research besides shows that yes there does exists a sense of fight between both the genders. Some other statements from literature reappraisal that supports our consequence and treatment show consequences such as Men perform better than adult females but the difference in their public presentation depends on the specific undertaking. Men can work out more games than adult females. Work force are more likely to look as leaders. to be directing and hierarchal to rule in groups. Men put in notably more attempt than adult females. Work force were found to be more concerted with other work forces than adult females were during same-gender interactions. Men compete more than what is best for them. These were some statements that supported men’s success. However there were some impersonal statements every bit good that had their ain position points in support for both the genders. some researches even specified certain countries for the accomplishments of both the genders. The statements from researches back uping merely misss were quiet less than those back uping male childs.

Following is the division of researches from literature reappraisal back uping male childs. misss and those of impersonal statements.

Previous Researches in Support
Boys Girls Neutral

20 % 50 % 30 %

VALIDITY OF OUR RESEARCH Validity in footings of old researches As most of the old researches that were conducted based on the subject of gender difference in accomplishing success showed that male childs are more high winners and successful than misss which is same as the result of our research so we can state that in footings of old researches our research is valid. Cogency in footings of Hypothesis Our initial hypothesis had clearly depicted that male childs can execute better than misss and this statement justly goes with our consequences. hence this research is valid in footings of what it was suppose to mensurate.

Restriction OF THIS RESEARCH While carry oning this research and seeking to accomplish satisfactory consequences. there were certain restrictions that somehow played their function in doing our research non a perfect one and hence can non be neglected. The really first restriction that we really faced while carry oning this experimental research was inaccessibility of our coveted location. As for this experiment we had to do the participants play a game of hints. so the location that we had planned for this experiment was suppose to be more broad. holding different options that may lend in doing the hints more slippery for the participants to judge but we were merely allowed to carry on this experiment within our university premises and that besides in our schoolrooms. If this research was conducted in a larger country so we would hold been able to supply this research with better grounds of squad work. It is a fact that pull offing a squad of more members is hard than of pull offing the lupus erythematosus. our coveted members were about 6 to 7 for each squad but we merely managed to acquire a sum of four participant to play as the members of their misss and male childs squads severally. this research would hold come up with more accurate consequences if a larger no of members had participated.

Another restriction for this research was our limited handiness of clip to carry on experiment. As planned. this experiment required a batch of clip dedication as some hard yet interesting hints were to be decided and hidden into their several topographic points for the participants to calculate them out ; clear instructions were to be provided to the participants and so after these readyings the existent game had to begun. therefore the entire clip planned for this experiment was about one and a half hr but due the prevalent fortunes. this experiment was really conducted in approximately half an hr. RECOMMENDATIONS In future if related researches are to be conducted. following recommendations can be made to accomplish satisfactory consequences. or possibly if we had considered the undermentioned recommendations it would had been more good for our research.

? The experiment for the research should be a individual blind experiment where the participants really don’t cognize what is being expected from them ; all they should cognize is that they have to play a game. In this manner more natural consequences sing their behavior can be obtained. ? As we are seeking to mensurate gender based squad direction and their success. hence. the sample size i. e. the no of members in each group should be in greater no so that the squad direction accomplishments can be clearly observed. ? The undertaking provided for both the genders to accomplish should be a bit conceptual but non excessively much physical to extinguish the intervention of gender difference ( i. e. male childs can of course execute physical undertakings better than misss ) as it would be quiet undue for the misss.

Mentions

Beverly Keyes Taylor. Gender Brain Chemistry – Teamwork is Different For Men and Women Canaray & A ; Dindia. ( 2006 ) Sexual activity Differences and Similarities in Communication Dr Andrew J. Martin ( 2002 ) Bettering the educational results of male childs. AJ Martin Research

Niederle. M. and Vesterlund. L. ( 2005 ) . Do adult females shy off from competition? Mimeo. Nowell. C. and Tinkler. S. ( 1994 ) . The influence of gender on the proviso of a public good. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization. 25. 25-36.

Radosveta Ivanova-Stenzel and Dorothea Kubler ( 2005 ) Courtesy and idling: gender differences in squad work and squad competition

Remy Melina ( September 2011 ) Article: Work force are squad participants. excessively. LiveScience Staff Writer

Shrage. ( 1999 ) Why Can’t a Woman Be More Like a Man? Retrieved October 16. 2006. from Academic Search Premier

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

x

Hi!
I'm Katy

Would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out