Police Response to Domestic Violence Essay

Free Articles

In 2005. the Bureau of Justice Statistics reported that 1. 181 females were killed by an intimate spouse. That means mundane. 3 adult females are killed as a consequence of domestic force. These overpowering statistics besides province that out of all the adult females murdered in the United States. one out of three of the slayings are the direct consequence of an intimate spouse. Domestic force is a form of opprobrious behaviour that includes whether sexual. emotional or physically. that is imposed by a spouse in an confidant relationship. This has been a major job in the United States and for decennaries domestic force continues to increase.

We acknowledge that domestic force continues to be an epidemic on the rise. Harmonizing to Eve S. Buzawa and Carl G. Buzawa. reform of police action in domestic assault instances has been a perennial subject for 20 old ages ( Dunham & A ; Albert. 2010. pg. 137 ) . Unfortunately. the traditional constabulary response affecting domestic force assaults still seems to take case in point. Law enforcement maintains their reactive attack by agencies of avoiding intercessions. testing out calls or prolonging the attitude that domestic force is non a existent offense.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

However. the issue sing the deficiency of presence and concern for domestic force victims goes beyond the stereotyped grounds why jurisprudence enforcement do non take a more proactive attack. The grounds may include personal attitudes. deficiency of preparation or even fright. However. when domestic instances involve minorities. jurisprudence enforcement has been known to go suspiciously bias. Nonetheless. domestic force is non merely limited to
male and female relationships. Homosexuals are besides involved in domestic force differences as good and officers peculiarly avoid intercession in these instances even more than heterosexual relationships.

In this study. we will research the different features affecting constabulary responses to domestic force. the grounds why jurisprudence enforcement hesitate in their response. and the different statistics affecting intercession in heterosexual. homosexual and minority families.

Avoiding Intervention

We have acknowledged through many texts and the experience of our fellow officers that police work is a really everyday profession. The high spots we visualize on telecasting shows are largely for amusement intents. In world. constabulary work consists of domestic force intercessions. which besides includes instances of drug maltreatment. Unfortunately. constabulary intercessions in domestic force instances still lack a proactive response.

Although today Domestic Violence intercession still needs to be revised in doing calls of service more productive. it was non until the early 1970’s when doing an apprehension for felonies without a warrant were non legal ( Doak. 2010. pg. 150 ) . Merely 14 of those provinces allowed the same protocol for misdemeanours and since assault and battery is a misdemeanour. victims were forced to do their ain felon charges. which resulted in deficiency of apprehensions and deficiency of doing a study ( Doak. 2010. pg. 150 ) . Fortunately since 2006. new legislative assembly has authorized warrant less likely cause for misdemeanor apprehensions in all provinces refering domestic force instances ( Doak. 2010. pg. 150 ) but jurisprudence enforcement continues to demo a deficiency of enthusiasm in doing apprehensions.

Harmonizing to writers. Roger G. Dunham and Geoffrey P. Albert. there are several grounds refering the reluctance to react to domestic force calls. The common issues that involve jurisprudence enforcements deficiency of intercession include: Organizational hindrances. deficiency of preparation. fright of hurt and most significantly police attitudes. Domestic force is misdemeanor. so in consequence constabulary officers don’t think of this assault as a “real” offense. They avoid doing apprehension as to reason that domestic force is a waste of clip. It’s common for police response to a domestic force state of affairs to miss enthusiasm or prolong doing an visual aspect at all.

However. fright is besides an imperative ground that causes jurisprudence enforcement to waver in the engagement of domestic force instances. Until late. constabulary officers weren’t aware of the proper protocol in managing domestic force instances. Besides. in many instances the victim can besides turn out to be the attacker when an officer efforts to do an apprehension. This can be a convincing hindrance in deficiency of constabulary response. The most of import ground I would wish to discourse is police attitudes towards domestic force instances and victims. The grounds I mention above are all features that contribute to the deficiency of engagement ; nevertheless the single attitude of the officer topographic points much accent on their actions.

Victim Statisticss

Approximately 1. 3 million adult females are physically assaulted by an confidant spouse yearly in the United States. In a 1995–1996 survey conducted through the 50 provinces including the District of Columbia. it was found that about 25 % of adult females were raped and/or physically assaulted by a current or former partner. live togethering spouse. or dating/acquaintance at some clip in their life-time ( American Bar Association. 2010 ) . Harmonizing to the U. S. Department of Justice. between 1998 and 2002. of the about 3. 5 million offenses committed against household members. about half of these were offenses against partners. Eighty-four of those spouse maltreatment victims were females. In 2001. confidant spouse force made up 20 % of all nonfatal violent offense experience by adult females. In 2000. 1. 247 adult females were killed by their confidant spouse ( American Bar Association. 2010 ) .

Two old ages ago my best friend was a portion of these overpowering statistics. For about three old ages she found herself in a really opprobrious relationship with her so fellow who is now the male parent of her three-year-old kid. The late dark calls I received maintain me on border because I merely continued to worry when I was traveling to acquire that fatal call that my best friend was dead. There were legion efforts of flight but like most of these adult females. “love” can sometimes be a expletive. Fortunately. my friend was able to interrupt away from her maltreater. Unfortunately. turning to the statistics I mentioned above. all are non so lucky.

Although traveling through that experience with my best friend was one of the hardest things in my life. cognizing that there were legion efforts to seek aid from jurisprudence enforcement to merely be ignored angered me more. As I discussed earlier. constabulary officers are non concerned with victims of domestic force. At least that’s what many victims say including my best friend. Victims are non taken earnestly because the misdemeanour offense is non taken earnestly. Regardless of your race. being a victim of an intimate spouse relationship continues to acquire the back place. Surveies have shown that certain features do play a important portion of how a constabulary officer will move to an single call for service. In instances of domestic force constabulary attitudes towards adult females. different races. and even sexual penchant has played a elaborate portion between doing apprehensions and stating an maltreater to merely take a walk and chill off.

Victim Features

“One in three adult females will see domestic force in her lifetime…” said Kathy Doherty. an executive manager of an association named Between Friends ( Chaney. K. . 2008 ) . It is really distressing to be cognizant of these statistics and still miss the support from jurisprudence enforcement to take the affairs earnestly. It’s even more unsettling to cognize that your race will play a important function in how a constabulary officer will exert his/her ain discretion.

In surveies I have read. theoreticians believe that when we evaluate the relationship between domestic force victims and constabularies response. institutional racism becomes a term widely used to specify the relationship. Harmonizing to the Macpherson Report’s definition:

‘Institutional Racism consists of the corporate failure of an organisation to supply an appropriate and professional service to people because of their colour. civilization or cultural beginning. It can be seen or detected in procedures. attitudes and behaviour which sum to favoritism through unintentional bias. ignorance. inconsideration. and racialist pigeonholing which disadvantage minority cultural people’ ( Belur. J. . 2008. pg. 428 ) .

Harmonizing to Amanda L. Robinson and Megham S. Chandek. writers of Differential Police Response to Black Battered Women. stated “not merely are coloured adult females. . . handicapped on history of their sex. but they are about everyplace baffled and mocked because of their race. Not merely because they are adult females. but because they are colored women” ( Chandek. M. S. . & A ; Robinson. A. L. . ( 2000 ) . pg. 30 ) . Institutionalized racism is the really pestilence that has made constabularies responses to domestic force calls for service uneffective. Minority ethic adult females have non been treated reasonably affecting many histories including sexism and racism. Today. gender and cultural backgrounds are grounds for their ailments to be handled “differently” . Harmonizing to studies made by the National Crime Victimization Survey and the FBI ( homicide studies ) . Black females experienced domestic force at a rate 35 % higher than that of white females. and about 22 times the rate of adult females of other races ( Newton. C. J. 2009 ) .

Minority Women are non the lone category that suffers from favoritism when measuring proactive constabulary response. The LGBT community has besides been a victim of sexism when seeking aid from jurisprudence enforcement in domestic force instances. Take this illustration from the article. Stonewalled: Police Abuse and Misconduct Against Lesbian. Gay and Transgender People in the U. S. :

A homosexual Filipino adult male was reportedly beaten on several occasions by his spouse. a white U. S. citizen. who was reportedly addicted to drugs and intoxicant. When constabulary responded to one affray. they reportedly arrested the Filipino adult male and threatened to describe him to in-migration governments. stating: “You’re non a citizen. We should behave you. you shouldn’t be hitting Americans ; you’re non an American. ” The Filipino adult male was sentenced to 52 hebdomads of batterer’s intercession in tribunal ( Amnesty International USA. 2010 )

This type of unfairness is unacceptable particularly in a topographic point where our Victims Rights and Human Rights are supposed to protect us. Cultural backgrounds. gender or sex should ne’er play a important function in how a police officer addresses a call for service in a domestic force instance or any instance. Institutional Racism must be abolished from our patterns of managing violent victim’s instances irrespective of certain features of the victim.

Changes for Reform

Fortunately. we as a state have come frontward to non merely turn to the jobs affecting constabulary response in domestic force instances but to besides advance a solution. There have been commissions and societal groups. such as Battered Women Advocates. who have helped to distribute the consciousness of domestic force. Besides the Minneapolis Domestic Violence experiment ( 1981-1982 ) has besides played a important portion in happening a “far more effectual manner to discourage future force than simply separation of the parties or officer mediation” ( Dunham R. G. & A ; Albert. G. P. ( 2010 ) . pg. 147 ) .

Although assaults and batteries are misdemeanours. arousing public involvement in the issue can put limitless force per unit areas on our condemnable justness system. Law enforcement bureaus have developed programs and in-service preparations to do officers reacting to domestic force instances more comfy and cognizant of their options. Training besides leads to a lessening of fright of hurt when nearing volatile state of affairss. The most outstanding federal response happened in 1994. when the Violence Against Women Act was passed to assist the battle to halt force against adult females.

Decision

Law enforcement plays a critical function in our condemnable justness system. Although constabulary officers are merely regular citizens in unvarying. we still keep them to a higher criterion compared to the general populace. We must understand that this state as a clasp must work together to halt force against adult females ( or work forces ) and the aid of the legion jurisprudence enforcement bureaus is more than needed. This study was designed to reflect a visible radiation on the many issues environing calls for service in domestic force instances. It’s non to propose that all constabulary officers are racist. male chauvinist or homo-phobic. However. we must remain on top of the issue to better accomplish in the success of halting institutional racialist attitudes. It will ever get down with that person who is behind the uniform that is reacting to a call. To go on to bring forth treatment will merely do the issue of domestic force affecting constabulary interaction an issue of the yesteryear.

Mentions

American Bar Association. ( 2010 ) . Commission of Domestic

Violence. Retrieved May 16. 2010. from hypertext transfer protocol: //new. abanet. org/domesticviolence/Pages/Statistics. aspx

Amnesty International USA. ( 2010 ) . Stonewalled: Police Abuse and

Misconduct Against Lesbian. Gay and Transgender People in the U. S. Retrieved May 16. 2010. from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. amnestyusa. org/lgbt-human-rights/stonewalled-a-report/police-response/page. make? id=1106617

Belur. Jyoti. ( 2008 ) . Is patroling domestic force

institutionally racist? A instance survey of south Asiatic Women. Patroling and Society. Volume 18. Issue 4. pg. 426-444.

Bureau of Justice Statistics. ( 2009 ) . Prison Statistics.

Retrieved October 27. 2009. from

hypertext transfer protocol: //www. ojp. usdoj. gov/bjs/prisons. htm

Chaney. K. ( 2008 ) . Domestic Violence hits Black Women Harder.

Chicago Defender Online.

Doak. M. J. ( 2007 ) . Domestic Violence. Law Enforcement. and Court

Responses to Domestic Violence. Child Abuse and Domestic Violence. 147-165.

Dunham. R. G. . & A ; Albert. G. P. ( 2010 ) . Critical Issues in

Patroling. Illinois. Waveland Press.

Newton. C. J. ( 2009 ) . Domestic Violence: An Overview. Retrieved

May 16. 2010. from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. findcounseling. com/journal/domestic-violence/domestic-violence-statistics. hypertext markup language

Robinson. A. L. . & A ; Chandek. M. S. ( 2000 ) . Differential Police

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

x

Hi!
I'm Katy

Would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out