Client Server Essay, Research Paper
The Mouse Trap // It seems that & # 8217 ; s everyone & # 8217 ; s angry with Mickey, from the left and right. But the choler is truly centered on the manner the Walt Disney Co. reflects our civilization and the values we all say we uphold.
Star Tribune ; Minneapolis, Minn. ; Jan 10, 1998 ; Martha Sawyer Allen ; Staff Writer ;
Sub Title: [ METRO Edition ]
Column Name: Faith & A ; Valuess
Start Page: 05B
ISSN: 08952825
Abstraction:
Religious conservativists decry what they say is the Walt Disney Co. & # 8217 ; s travel off from “ household values and household amusement to advance a homosexual docket. ” Liberal adult females & # 8217 ; s-rights groups have been angry for old ages at what they say are the stereotypes of adult females in the sketchs. And politically broad social-justice advocators decry what they say are the poverty-level on the job conditions in many Disney workss in the Third World.
Experts say that Mickey and Co. are targeted so frequently because they mirror our civilization & # 8211 ; excessively good. Disney International Relations and Security Network & # 8217 ; t in front of our civilization & # 8211 ; it is our civilization. And wear & # 8217 ; t bury that more people visit the Disney “ motherhouses ” & # 8211 ; Walt Disney World and Disneyland & # 8211 ; than any other subject Parkss in the universe.
However, all those groups besides display some ambivalency about Disney, and that says a batch about values issues in this state. How do you assail a company that has created so many digesting and endearing cultural icons? For better or worse, full coevalss of American kids have worked out many issues by watching Disney movies. Disney has the doubtful accomplishment of doing amusement as of import in society as work, religion, political relations and household.
Full Text:
Copyright Star Tribune Newspaper of the Twin Cities Jan 10, 1998
Sometimes campaigns make the strangest bedfellows. See the alliance of folks who have found a common American-values land: From spiritual conservativists to broad social-justice advocators many are reasoning that Mickey Mouse has, as one said, “ turned into a rat. ”
Religious conservativists decry what they say is the Walt Disney Co. & # 8217 ; s travel off from “ household values and household amusement to advance a homosexual docket. ” Liberal adult females & # 8217 ; s-rights groups have been angry for old ages at what they say are the stereotypes of adult females in the sketchs. And politically broad social-justice advocators decry what they say are the poverty-level on the job conditions in many Disney workss in the Third World.
Experts say that Mickey and Co. are targeted so frequently because they mirror our civilization & # 8211 ; excessively good. Disney International Relations and Security Network & # 8217 ; t in front of our civilization & # 8211 ; it is our civilization. And wear & # 8217 ; t bury that more people visit the Disney “ motherhouses ” & # 8211 ; Walt Disney World and Disneyland & # 8211 ; than any other subject Parkss in the universe.
What makes this peculiar battle more interesting, many experts add, is that it doesn & # 8217 ; t follow any ordinary culture-and-values war book. Everyone & # 8217 ; s angry with Disney.
“ Probably no value-laden group hasn & # 8217 ; t criticized Disney for non stand foring its concerns & # 8211 ; adequately, or rightly, ” said Brenda Brasher, who teaches about faith and popular civilization at Mount Union College in Alliance, Ohio.
The Southern Baptist Convention approved a boycott last summer of Walt Disney Co. to protest what it says is the amusement giant & # 8217 ; s travel off from “ household values ” and its indorsement of “ immoral political orientations ” for accepting homosexualism in its employment policies.
Other spiritual conservativists, including the Assemblies of God, the Church of the Nazarene and the Catholic League, besides are involved, including James Dobson & # 8217 ; s Focus on the Family.
At the same clip the United Methodist Church has confronted Disney for what the church says are Disney & # 8217 ; s near-slave rewards to foreign workers, compared with the astronomical sum paid to its caput, Michael Eisner. ( Think in footings of approximately 50 cents a twenty-four hours vs. $ 500 million in a erstwhile stock payment. )
The denominations represent more than 50 million Americans.
That doesn & # 8217 ; t get down to number adult females who are upset with the function theoretical accounts exemplified by most of the female leads in Disney sketchs. You know, incapacitated Barbie dolls, or evil, witch-like stepmothers.
Emotional images
However, all those groups besides display some ambivalency about Disney, and that says a batch about values issues in this state. How do you assail a company that has created so many digesting and endearing cultural icons? For better or worse, full coevalss of American kids have worked out many issues by watching Disney movies. Disney has the doubtful accomplishment of doing amusement as of import in society as work, religion, political relations and household.
Even Richard Land, whose Southern Baptist organisation is forcing the boycott, admitted in a picture that Disney is the “ custodian of powerful emotional images that we grew up with & # 8211 ; Mickey Mouse, Donald Duck and the Magic Kingdom. ” Because of that, he continued, “ our guard is frequently down. ”
But, unhappily, he said, “ The mouse has turned into a rat. ”
How make you boycott a company that controls so much? If you & # 8217 ; re upset with Disney, do you besides so retreat from ABC-TV and wireless, ESPN and E! overseas telegram channels, Hyperion books and Miramax Films? While it may be easy to avoid Disney subject Parkss, you might be the lone household on the block non to travel. How do you avoid the mercantile establishment ware shops and the other 200 Disney subordinates? They & # 8217 ; re even purchasing athleticss franchises now.
The Rev. Paul Wellinghoff has found a partial solution. His boy and girl used to watch “ Cinderella, ” “ Bambi, ” “ Snow White ” and other Disney movies over and over once more.
No longer. Now they get their amusement from NEST Entertainment and characteristics distributed by Focus on the Family. Wellinghoff, who is curate of Crystal Lake Baptist Church in Burnsville, said, “ We merely explained to our kids that in a Christian household we try to make the things that Jesus would desire us to and we don & # 8217 ; t want to back up something that Jesus wouldn & # 8217 ; t support. ”
Besides, he said, “ We & # 8217 ; ve introduced them to a batch of other new things. There & # 8217 ; s more to life than Disney. ”
Is that you, John? & lt ;
/p >
The Rev. John Tanner of Southtown Baptist Church in Bloomington said he wore a set of Mickey Mouse ears to a meeting with his fellow Southern Baptist curates late. “ I got what I wanted, ” he said with a laugh. “ An immediate shot. ”
However, Tanner and Wellinghoff say that they support the attempt to convey to the state & # 8217 ; s attending the fact that a pudding stone that purports to be a family-friendly company has all sorts of amusement that would non be welcome in many places.
At the same clip both work forces say their folds have conflicting feelings about the boycott. While people are non happy with the content of many Disney movies and other amusement points, they & # 8217 ; re divide on whether an economic boycott is the manner to travel.
Neither adult male has preached from the dais about the issues, but they have both heard & # 8211 ; and led & # 8211 ; informal treatments about it.
Tanner said, “ We want to take a moral stance. It & # 8217 ; s like a public statement that we don & # 8217 ; t like the way of ethical motives in the state. ”
Even though Disney, for many, exemplifies what & # 8217 ; s incorrect with American moral values, “ traveling to Disneyland or Disney World is the same sort of pilgrim’s journey for many households & # 8211 ; the figure one finish & # 8211 ; similar to cathedrals for pilgrims in Medieval Europe, ” said Mount Union & # 8217 ; s Brasher. While mediaeval pilgrims wanted to touch spiritual relics in cathedrals in an effort “ to touch the transcendent, ” contemporary Disney pilgrims journey to topographic points of pleasance. “ It & # 8217 ; s an internally directed end now, ” she said.
Tanner and Brasher see small incorrect with Disney subject Parkss. “ I merely can & # 8217 ; Ts say that Disneyland or Disney World are bad topographic points, ” said Tanner, who has gone to both.
Brasher said, “ What impressed me about Christianity when I was a kid was that Jesus welcomed small kids. I felt good about that. I wasn & # 8217 ; t so certain about the church, but Jesus was clear. Today, we talk about `family values, & # 8217 ; but so few of our public topographic points are child welcoming. Disney, to its great recognition and market orientation, is child encompassing. In a child-unfriendly society, that & # 8217 ; s really appealing. ”
Cultural values
Karal Ann Marling, a University of Minnesota cultural historiographer who has taught categories about Disney, said, “ There & # 8217 ; s a whole species of Disney movies that have cultural values embedded in them strongly. Cinderella is draw a bead oning to be a 1950s homemaker. She & # 8217 ; s desperate to pin down a hubby. She doesn & # 8217 ; t want to travel to college. ” “ Cinderella ” was foremost released in 1950. Movies like “ Cinderella ” work out the cultural preoccupations of the twenty-four hours, Marling says.
Besides, much like the Brothers Grimm faery narratives of earlier coevalss, the movies work out hard and painful things for kids & # 8211 ; things they may non experience comfy speaking over with their parents. For illustration, Bambi loses his female parent in a awful fire. Snow White and Cinderella have evil stepmothers. Dumbo & # 8217 ; s female parent is taken from him and jailed.
But one thing the experts remind us of is that in those films the “ kids ” survive. Bambi makes friends and does all right. Dumbo learns to “ wing ” on his ain. Cinderella and Snow White “ acquire ” prince charming. The films assure kids that life frequently works out for the best.
Marling adds, if the dissenters “ are traveling to fault anyone it should be the civilization at big and non Disney. ”
James Dobson, of Focus on the Family, said in a picture, “ We & # 8217 ; re non trying to injure or ache people who are homosexual or sapphic. We & # 8217 ; re speaking about the docket of a motion that we must oppose. It & # 8217 ; s anti-Christian from top to bottom. ”
The Disney Co. , for its portion, does non look excessively cowed by the boycott. In a statement it said, “ We are proud that the Disney trade name creates more household amusement of every sort than anyone else in the universe. We plan to increase our leading function. ”
The Rev. Bruce Forbes, who teaches faith and popular civilization at Morningside College in Sioux City, Iowa, said popular civilization is like a “ funhouse mirror. The basic premise of popular cultural analysis is that popular civilization both reflects us and determine us. Disney would non be cardinal to the civilization if we weren & # 8217 ; t reacting to the extent it reflects us. It & # 8217 ; s non a pure contemplation, nevertheless. We see ourselves, but non precisely. ”
Cultural ambivalency
A new study of Baptist churchs in America reported that less than one-third agreed with the boycott and, of those who supported the boycott thought, merely 48.8 per centum reported avoiding purchasing Disney merchandises.
The canvass was conducted by the Southern Research Group of Jackson, Miss. , for the Associated Baptist Press, and was a random sample telephone study of Baptist churchs in the 14 provinces where most of the Southern Baptists live. The study reported that support for the boycott was weak in about all groups surveyed.
Among those Baptist churchs who said the Southern Baptist Convention stand best represents their point of position, 14.3 per centum said they agree with the boycott, while 15.8 strongly agree. But 26.7 per centum disagreed and 28.2 per centum strongly disagreed. The remainder were impersonal.
Patrick Anderson, former frailty president of the Florida Baptist Convention and a sociologist at Florida Southern College in Lakeland, said, “ I travel a good trade, and it & # 8217 ; s interesting that major airdromes have a Disney shop. All the promenades do. It & # 8217 ; s an unbelievable transnational corporation, and genuinely a diverse company. You can & # 8217 ; t assist but happen something to be huffy at, whether you & # 8217 ; re on the left or right. But is a boycott traveling to work? Of class non. ”
Tanner said he wishes a more positive manner could be found to speak about the values in our civilization and the ways they are reflected in Disney.
“ As Christians we are non to near the universe in a negative frame of head. We have the bounds Christ taught us, but we & # 8217 ; re universe confirming. It & # 8217 ; s God & # 8217 ; s universe. We & # 8217 ; rhenium here to be the salt, the visible radiation, the leaven. For us to sit in a reactionist place and so onslaught is non Christian. ”
[ Illustration ]
Illustration
Reproduced with permission of the right of first publication proprietor. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
