This paper presents a review of a qualitative research article titled: ‘Perceived support from healthcare practicians among grownups with type 2 diabetes’ ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) ( appendix 1 ) . To enable the review of this article the Caldwell reviewing tool ( 2005 ) will be utilized. ( Appendix 2 )
Research critiquing is a valuable accomplishment, to derive as it enables pupil nurses to develop and better cognition and accomplishments and besides adheres to the NMC codification of behavior ( NMC, 2008 ) . Polit and Beck ( 2006 ) accent the ability to analyze research enables persons to derive cognition. A great importance of research is that it introduces betterments and alterations into pattern based from grounds based pattern ( EBP ) . Harmonizing to Pioneer David Sacklett ( 2000 ) . EBP can be defined as “the integrating of the best research grounds and clinical expertness, and patient values” ( Sacklett,2000 ) . This article was selected as diabetes is going an international epidemic impacting all health care professions ( WHO,2012 ) .
First point of involvement to a reader is the rubric ; giving clear indicant of the topic ( Polit and beck, 2012 ) . It should catch the attending of a reader as discussed by Parahoo ( 2006 ) . A good rubric should contemplate all facets of the above, besides sing Polit and Becks ( 2012 ) ideas on the rubric being with a 15 word bound. This rubric is really clear to the reader, in relation to the topic under survey being short, concise and usage of good linguistic communication.
Appropriate choice for a research paper relies extremely on cogency and dependability, which can be shown via certificates of writers. Working statues within wellness surveies and behavioral research within university of Stavanger clearly quoted against each of the writers. This article has clearly labelled, educational position and working position of all writers.
Willis ( 2007 ) believes that an author’s academic background can give cogency and credibleness within the research itself. Education held by writers was ‘MSc, PhD, RNT’ being of an university degree ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) .
Further involvement to a reader commences from the information shown within an abstract. This has to keep adequate information for it to demo a brief apprehension of the survey in topographic point. Holloway and Wheeler ( 2010 ) urge a clear, concise sum-up of the research and how it should be implemented. Burns and Grove ( 2007 ) reference good abstracts convey findings and capturing attending of a reader. A benefit to this article is that it is clear, clear and structured with subheadings supplying a deeper structured apprehension.
The debut of this article obviously outlines the principle for the survey ; with mention of findings from other relevant surveies completed. Holloway and Wheeler ( 2010 ) declare writers have to supply consciousness of their capable and grounds for their survey. Suggestions made indicated that it is paramount for survey for the betterments to be made, underscoring on the rise in statistics from the status ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) .
Within the article, there is no clear indicant of a literature reappraisal. Although, through reading this it has become evident that it has been included within the background subdivision. Polit and Beck ( 2012 ) discourse a literature reappraisal being a sum-up of old research. Explanations are given within mention to other surveies such as Schilling et Al ( 2002 ) which has shown to miss empirical grounds.
However, Thorne and Paterson ( 2001 ) expression at facets, but indicate more research can be done. The intent of a literature reappraisal is indispensable as it gives more accent on why the survey is of import ; for case deficiency of old research on the topic. Within this article has an disadvantage, because there is no clear stating of a literature reappraisal, which would in some fortunes confuse a reader. Research referenced within the article was between the old ages 1992-2008 ; adverting the demand for farther research ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) .
A intent for an article is to generalize at that place purposes, informing capable under survey saying what is likely to be accomplishable from the survey ; Polit and beck ( 2012 ) accent this being an importance. The purpose is clearly sub headed giving the reader clear placement within the study, it is short and concise with relevant information ; bespeaking the topic of survey and what is desired. The purpose being ‘perceived support from health care and different properties, that influence people’s self-management of the disease’ ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) .
The survey is complete by utilizing participants. Ethical issues have a huge importance associating to the cogency and credibleness of the research. Approval of ethical committee’s is exceeding, including mention. Legal rights and ethical facets for all research methods have to be considered ( Holloway and Wheeler, 2002 ; Moule 2011 ; Strubert, 2011 ) . The survey appears to hold been approved by Norse regional commission for medical and wellness research moralss, societal scientific discipline informations services all holding mention provided.
Deductions can be studied at length but four rights are paramount in research: the right non to be harmed, the right of full revelation, the right to self-government and the right to privateness, namelessness and confidentiality ( ICN, 2012 ) . It is evident from the survey that informed consent was gained from participants, as an invitation was sent, and blessing from participants was gained. The right to retreat was shown as two participants ne’er contributed from initial blessing.
Methodology is discussed by Parahoo ( 2007 ) merely as a program that describes, how, when and where information is to be collected and analysed. This article does non visibly demo methodological analysis but it is an interchangeable term such as research design is present. An advantage from the article is that farther reading and comprehension is non necessary as it evidently indicates this research as “interpretive and descriptive qualitative design” ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) . Holloway and Wheeler ( 2002 ) province it gives an apprehension of human experiences, giving an advantage to this research as it is what they wish to accomplish.
Additionally, Holloway and Wheeler ( 2010 ) discuss, how roots with linguistics and the human scientific discipline, particularly in history, centering the manner worlds related to their subjective world and attaching a significance
to it. Approach taken entirely on universe life context instead than individualism ; leting more of an apprehension of human experiences at a whole. This type of research allows writers to derive features within this field. Use of the information is to develop theories and place jobs with current pattern ( Burns and Grove, 2007 ; Gerrish and Lacey, 2010 ) .
Results achieved five subjects, viz. : an empathic attack, practical advice and information, engagement in determination devising, accurate and individualized information and on-going based support ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) . These are gained via interpretative and descriptive qualitative design, as it focusses more natural environments instead than cause and consequence which is quasi-experimental. This construct being perceptibly identified via the research, this was conducted.
Detailss of the participants can be found within the article visibly labelled participants. A participant enables the research worker to carry on the survey ; Burns and Grove ( 2012 ) suggest participants are selected due to see, cognition and positions related to the survey in the advancement helping the research worker to derive accurate information. Within this article, the type of trying which has been declared is purposive sampling ; Parahoo ( 2006 ) suggests that this type of trying conducted is chosen because it provides more dependable and valid informations as it is represented by participants diagnosed with the status. Furthermore the participants, who were invited to take portion, were recruited via referrals, from local administrations associating to diabetes such as acquisition and header. Ability to talk Norse and be within an age bracket of 30-65 allows the informations to be more accurate.
As discussed, trying was purposeful ; therefore it emphasises the dependability. The sample size used for this research was 19 participants recruited from 3 administrations, unemployed to cut down prejudice. Assorted gender, aged 30-65 and all participants had the status for a lower limit of one twelvemonth. Although, purposive sampling is used it does non bespeak which scheme ; for case, Patton ( 2002 ) allocates more than 12 for qualitative research, Polit and Beck ( 2012 ) note there being no fixed regulations for sample size, although Morse ( 2000 ) mentions how much wide the range, reflects in the sample size. This research has an advantage as it focussed on participants whom are diabetic. However restrictions being restricted are age group, and metabolic generalization. For illustration: participants within the survey all had the controlled blood glucose degrees, there was no sample members who shown uncontrolled or unstable diabetes.
Data aggregation from the research conducted was presented within a tabular array. Collected via focal point groups, dwelling of 6-7 individual per session, participants were interviewed at the workplace of the writers and mixture of genders per group. Although as mentioned by Polit and Hungler ( 1997 ) advantage being that it increases duologue ; disadvantage being an lessening for those non comfy voicing within a group. As it has it pros and cons we can set up that all participants’ had type 2 disease hence would non hold much influence on responses.
Limits of clip, and for 2 Sessionss was placed by research workers. The writers recommended clip for contemplation between Sessionss. The theoretical accounts used, were identified with the informations aggregation subdivision being expectancy-value and societal support theory for inquiries within the focal point groups. All the participants spoke one linguistic communication ; Norse which is an advantage to others as it is easier to transcribe.
The focal point groups explained in informations analysis was audiotaped and transcribed verbatim, making auditability. The analysis was as declared “Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: Concepts, processs and steps to accomplish trustworthiness” ( Graneheim and Lundman, 2004 ; Oftedal et Al, 2010, p1503 ) . Procedures took topographic point for this survey, unmistakably shown as coding to breakdown text into parts ; placing forms within the information ( Burns and Grove, 2006 ; Holland and Rees, 2010 ) . After placing codifications, this enables the subjects to be developed which was interrelated as findings of the survey. Furthermore, information direction requires clear procedures to guarantee methodological cogency and credibleness of the findings ( Burns and Grove, 2007 ) . Harmonizing to Polit and Beck ( 2006 ) a reader should see if the information is equal, to be published in a clear and efficient mode. This article has suitably labelled right doing it clear and apprehensible.
The consequences gained from the information analysis, is clearly drawn within the article under the findings subdivision ; supplying the established subjects, making an apprehension for the reader of how and why they found referenced subjects. Polit and Beck ( 2013 ) discourse how a reader should notably happen restrictions within the survey. this article presents a restriction subdivision sketching a treatment of how it affects the consequences and farther references possible questions that can be made such as, different properties that can be found from people without stable metabolic ranges as it was limited to acceptable metabolic degrees ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) . The impact of consequences found can build towards EBP. Additionally, the writers have discussed deductions for pattern within the survey. This advantage is a favorable point as it leads the reader of the deductions and how it can be implemented. It focuses enormously on how good it is when it comes to pattern.
Harmonizing to transferability of these findings it becomes evident that type 2 diabetes is a world-wide increasing job. Consequences can be movable to any state to better better attention for those with type 2 diabetes. The survey was conduct in Norway, although it is based within another state the prevalence is still applicable in the UK. Holloway and Wheeler ( 2010 ) discourse the significance of transferability as “findings of one context that can be transferred to similar state of affairss or participants” diabetes is a world-wide known disease ( WHO, 2012 ) it can be transferred.
Polit and Beck ( 2013 ) mention that for the generalization of the survey ; it has to be valid and dependable for this to take topographic point. The function of a nurse becomes paramount within this subdivision. Whether the consequences can be implemented by a nurse in pattern, such as back uping patients in a better mode and mentioning if needed for more instruction, giving more individualization to self-management programmes as discussed within the article ( Oftedal et al, 2010 ) .
In relation to the decision within the article it clearly sums up the findings and how it can be implemented within pattern. It states that farther research is necessary before definite decisions can be retained. Transferability of the research to other chronic unwellness similar to type 2 diabetes was besides mentioned. Burns and Grove ( 2010 ) express that the findings and the significance of the research should be placed within the decision.
The assignment has explored the significance within research and EBP, transferability of research and recommendation have an importance in this. Overall, this article was clear with good usage of words, presentation was greatly achieved, leting the reader to be more focused. It discussed within itself the restrictions, recommendations and the demand for farther research for this to go meaningful. Recommendations can be viewed as cognition and implemented within pattern from this survey. Besides demoing that grounds based pattern does get down from research ; it is shown that surveies are required in some fortunes to derive more cognition to better services.
Mentions
Nathan birnbaums, N, Grove, S K ( 2006 ) Understanding nursing research: Building an grounds based pattern 4th erectile dysfunction Elsevier Saunders, United States of America
Nathan birnbaums, N, Grove, S K ( 2007 ) Understanding nursing research: Constructing an evidence-based pattern. 5th erectile dysfunction. Elsevier Saunders, United States of AmericaCaldwell, K. , Henshaw, L. , and Taylor, G. ( 2005 ) Developing a frame-work for reviewing wellness research, Journal of wellness, societal and envi-ronmental issues, 6 ( 1 ) , pp45-53. [ accessed via: hypertext transfer protocol: //eprints.mdx.ac.uk/2981/1/Developing_a_framework_for_critiquing_health_research.pdf ] [ accessed 20/05/2013 ]
Cutcliffe, J. and Ward, M. ( explosive detection systems. ) ( 2007 ) Reviewing nursing research. 2nd erectile dysfunction. London: Quay Books.
Gerrish, K and Lacey, a ( 2010 ) The reseach procedure in nursing 6th Ed Blackwell publication: Oxford
Graneheim, UH. & A ; Lundman, B. ( 2004 ) . Qualitative content analysis in nursing
research: Concepts, processs and steps to accomplish trustiness. Nurse Education Today, 24, pp. 105-112. [ accessed via: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.nurseeducationtoday.com/article/S0260-6917 ( 03 ) 00151-5/abstract ] [ accessed 20/05/2013 ]
Holland, K. and Rees, C. ( 2010 ) Nursing: evidence-based pattern accomplishments. New York: Oxford University Press.
Holloway, I, Wheeler, S ( 2002 ) qualitative research in nursing 2nd erectile dysfunction. Blackwell publication: Oxford
Holloway, I, Wheeler, S ( 2010 ) qualitative research in nursing and health care 3rd erectile dysfunction. Blackwell publication: Oxford
ICN ( international council of nurses ) ( 2012 ) ethical guidelines for nursing research. Geneva ; ICN [ accessed via hypertext transfer protocol: //www.icn.ch/images/stories/documents/publications/free_publications/Code_of_Ethics_2012.pdf ] accessed 20/05/2013.
Morse, Janice, M. ( 2000 ) . Determining sample size. Qualitative Health Research, 10 ( 1 ) , 3-5. [ accessed via hypertext transfer protocol: //qhr.sagepub.com/content/10/1/3.extract ] accessed 20/05/2013
Moule, P, Hek, J ( 2011 ) Making sense of reseach ; an debut for wellness and societal attention practioners. 4th erectile dysfunction. Sage publications: London
Nursing & A ; Midwifery Council ( 2008 ) The codification: criterions of behavior, public presentation and moralss for nurses and accoucheuses. London: Nursing and Midwifery Council.
Oftedal, B, Karlsen, B, Bru E. ( 2010 ) Perceived support from healthcare practioners among grownups with type 2 diabetes. Journal of advanced nursing, vol 66, issue 7, pp1500-1509. Blackwell printing [ accessed via hypertext transfer protocol: //onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2010.05329.x/abstract ] [ accessed on 01/03/2013 ]
Patton, M Q ( 2002 ) : Qualitative Research & A ; Evaluation Methods, Sage: Thousand Oaks.
Parahoo, K. ( explosive detection systems. ) ( 2006 ) Nursing research: rules, procedure and issues. 2nd erectile dysfunction. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. ( explosive detection systems. ) ( 2012 ) Nursing research: generating and measuring grounds for nursing pattern. 9th erectile dysfunction. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. ( explosive detection systems. ) ( 2006 ) Necessities of nursing attention: methods, assessment and use. 6th erectile dysfunction. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. ( explosive detection systems. ) ( 2010 ) Necessities of nursing research: evaluative grounds for nursing pattern. 7th erectile dysfunction. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. ( explosive detection systems. ) ( 2013 ) Necessities of nursing research: evaluative grounds for nursing pattern. 8th erectile dysfunction. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Polit, D F, Hungler, B P ( 1997 ) Necessities of nursing research ; methods, assessment and use. 4th Ed, Lippincott- Raven, Philadelphia: New York
David L. Sackett ( 2000 ) . Evidence based medical specialty ; how to pattern and Teach EBM. Volume 2 Edition, 2, Churchill Livingstone: University of Michigan.
Schilling L.S. , Grey M. & A ; Knafl K.A. ( 2002 ) The construct of selfmanagement of type 1 diabetes in kids and striplings: an
evolutionary construct analysis. Journal of Advanced Nursing 37 ( 1 ) , 87–99.accessed via: .http: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11784402 [ Accessed 20/05/2013 ]
Streubert, H J, Carpenter, D R ( 2011 ) Qualitative research in nursing: progressing the humanistic imperative fifth Ed, Wolter Kluwer Lippincott Williams & A ; Williams: London. pp56-59
Thorne S.E. & A ; Paterson B.L. ( 2001 ) Health attention professional support for self-care direction in chronic unwellness: penetrations from diabetes research. Patient Education and Reding 42 ( 1 ) , 81–90.Accessed via: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11080608 [ Accessed 20/05/2013 ]
WHO. ( 2012 ) About WHO [ on-line ] . World Health Organization. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.who.int/about/en/ [ Accessed 17th December 2012 ] .
Willis, J, W. ( 2007 ) Foundations of qualitative research. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage.
