, Research Paper

John McCain, the Senator from Arizona, declared his campaigning for President on April 14, 1999, another name for the GOP ticket that was non made excessively much dither about. Not given much consideration was allotted to him by the Republican party constitution that has already selected its white knight who would win them the presidential term, Governor George Bush of Texas. But, Sen. McCain catapulted to national attending when he out of the blue won the New Hampshire primary floging the established favourite with a 19 point lead. Ever since so, his run has been heading down watercourse with important losingss suffered in Delaware, South Carolina, Washington, and Virginia. And his hapless screening on Super Tuesday including his failure to gaining control delegates in either the New York or California primaries has all but ended his command for the presidential term. The chief rationalisation of this ruin is because McCain did non appeal to Republican registered electors but other grounds besides include negative candidacy, both his response to them and his deficiency of utilizing them against his chief opposition, Bush. In add-on to these accounts, others besides include the personality factor and the deficiency of clip to run in these primaries as he had in New Hampshire. By analyzing these factors, it is easy to grok why the McCain campaign failed to win the bulk of primaries and procure the needed figure of delegates.

Before analysing the ruin of Senator McCain s run, and account of the Republican party and the Republican primary system is indispensable in understanding why it failed. The Republican party had its official beginnings as the resistance to the passage of the 1854 Kansas-Nebraska Act which stated that each district the right to make up one’s mind if bondage is permitted. Early Republican platforms appealed to commercial involvements as good and favored homesteading, internal betterments, building of a transcontinental railway and protective duties. After the North s triumph in the civil war, the Republican party reigned over the White House until the Great Depression and it declined even further with the popularity of the democratic President, Franklin D. Roosevelt. In the past fourty old ages, the Republican party attracted white southern Democrats, people who are more comfortable and better educated than Democratic protagonists and occupy managerial or professional place or run little concern, live in or travel into good to make suburban countries and are preponderantly Protestant. In the 1990s, conservative spiritual groups were attracted to the Republican party due to its anti-abortion and support for school supplication platforms and made a concentrated attempt to spread out their influence within a party. The rise of the Christian right amongst the Republican party has led to internal struggles between them and traditional Republicans and therefore, any campaigner who hopes to win the nomination must happen a agency to appeal to both.

The primary system was introduced at the beginning of the century by Progressive reformists in an effort to weaken the power of party leaders by taking campaigner nominations out of their custodies. Primary elections are used to choose each party s campaigners for the general election. At the Presidential degree, primary elections are indirect, they are used to choose province delegates to the national nomination conventions, at which the major party presidential campaigners are chosen. In some provinces, merely registered members of the party may vote in a primary election ( a closed primary ) , whereas other provinces allow all registered electors to make up one’s mind on the twenty-four hours of the primary in which party s primary they will take part ( unfastened primary ) , therefore, leting for cross over vote. The other manner of choosing a party s campaigners is caucuses, which are put uping procedures that begin with precinct degree meetings throughout the province. Once once more, the province decides whether or non the caucus is an unfastened or closed one. In caucuses delegates are elected to statewide conventions at which delegates to the national party are chosen. In some provinces that delegates are proportioned harmonizing to the ballot, for illustration New York, whereas in others there are winner take all competitions such as in California. A important inquiry for serious presidential campaigners is non whether they should travel into the primaries, alternatively, it is which peculiar 1s they should come in. Therefore, it is of import for the campaigners to execute good during the earlier primaries and caucuses such as New Hampshire and Iowa since it secures better media coverage for subsequent races. It is besides of import for campaigners to orient their messages depending of the province that they are runing in since concentrating on more broad issues in provinces that have unfastened primaries may increase the figure of crossover vote. Other considerations include the size of the province since the larger provinces have more delegates apportioned to them, therefore leting the campaigner to accomplish far greater additions by runing longer in larger provinces than they would in smaller provinces. And eventually, the geographical part is besides important since most Southern, Western and Southwestern provinces are have strong conservative values whereas the North East provinces tend to be more broad, the Midwest is divided equally between the two parties. This, excessively, requires the campaigner to orient his message so to appeal to the broadest base of electors. Therefore, for a campaigner to be competitory in the primaries or caucuses, he needs to a head start in New Hampshire, requires an drawn-out candidacy interval in larger provinces and demands to orient his message based on whether or non the province holds unfastened primaries and on the geographical location of the province.

The party established George Bush announced his command for the GOP nomination for presidential campaigner on June 12, 1999 and had raised by June 30th an unprecedented $ 36.2 million so far for his run, a record amount that dwarfs the money raised by his Republican oppositions. Not merely did he achieve the warchest to carry on his run but he besides had the overpowering support of the Republican party. So great was the indorsement of the party that the republican Governor of Arizona, Jane Hull, campaigned against the place town Senator. McCain s run, at the beginning, chiefly focused on the issue of run reform which led to even farther rejection by the GOP party who claimed that rejecting soft money would ache the party & # 8217 ; s traditional border in fund-raising by leting brotherhoods to maintain giving money to Democrats. Bush, on the other manus racked up farther points with the constitution by saying that rejecting soft money would ache Republicans and would give control of the authorities back to the Democrats and went on to back up the lift of the $ 1,000 contribution bound on soft money. The party s firm support for a campaigner is of import since party habitues tend to listen largely to their ain side of political statements and to hold with the policies espoused by their party. The campaigner supported by the Republican party is the 1 who receives most of the ballots since Studies in voting behaviour have found that the stronger a elector s designation with a peculiar party, the more likely is he to take the campaigner endorsed by that party. Therefore, by non deriving the bulk of the support of the Republican party, John McCain lost the Conservative elector base required to win many of the primaries and would non hold been able to capture any of the delegates in the upcoming closed primary elections..

McCain s message on run finance reform, utilizing the excess to shore up societal security instead than supplying a bigger revenue enhancement cut and being a reformist in general appealed to Democrats and mugwumps more than it did to the conservative Republican elector which hurt him in closed primaries and besides in primaries in which the democrats voted on the same twenty-four hours. The declaration by the McCain run of being the Republican reformists who can do this party bigger and alteration political relations for future coevalss was more attractive to Democrats and mugwumps than it was to conservativists who see alterations in one of the cardinal rules of the party as a negative determiner. This is seen in the polls of the Michigan primary, McCain had won, where he had won the Democratic ballot [ 18 % of entire ballot ] by a 4 to 1 ratio but Bush had got approximately two tierces of the Republican ballot. As Ari Fleischer, spokesman for the Bush run commented, & # 8221 ; The cardinal defect of the McCain campaigning is that it needs Democrats to win. You can & # 8217 ; t win the Republican nomination on the dorsums of Democrats. Even after doing addresss where he states that he is a Reagan conservative and that he loves the Republican Party, McCain still failed to capture the republican ballot in the following unit of ammunition of primaries in Washington, Virginia and North Dakota. The inquiry to be asked is had McCain promoted his vote record in Congress more zealously and revealed that the Americans for Democratic Action had given him a life-time broad vote norm of 9 per centum out of 100 and that the American Conservative Union declared him to hold a solidly conservative vote record, would he hold fared better in the primaries than he had touting his run finance reform docket? The effects of his determination to advance issues such as run finance reform cost him important ballots in closed primaries and besides on Super Tuesday where provinces that held unfastened primaries besides held democratic primaries on the same twenty-four hours, therefore doing a lessening in cross over vote. Hence, by non orienting his message to the republican elector, John McCain s run was condemned to failure.

McCain besides lost claim to the republican ballot due to his unfavorable judgment of spiritual leaders: Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell. Due to Bush s visit to Bob Jones in South Carolina and his deficiency of repudiation of the school s policies of anti-Catholic dogmatism and prohibition on interracial dating, it was deemed an unmistakable signal of solidarity with Christian Right. This claim was farther potentiated when Bush accepted the indorsement and assistance of Pat Robertson in South Carolina. McCain seized on Bush & # 8217 ; s address at fundamentalist Bob Jones University to propose that Bush stood soundless in the face of anti-Catholicism. And so, for good step, he accuses Robertson of being an agent of intolerance and Bush of being an agent of Robertson. By doing these remarks McCain alienated the Christian right which claims to hold 1.7 million members and 1,600 local affiliates and chapters in all 50 provinces and has a $ 25 million one-year budget. Though the figure of members may look undistinguished but about 30 % of the members of the Republican party claims to be a strong Christian and therefore, by estranging their leaders, McCain alienated a 3rd of the conservative elector, particularly in

Southern provinces. In the issue polls in Michigan, Bush carried two tierces of the Christian conservative electors and on Super Tuesday, Bush carried 83 % of their ballot in Georgia and 74 % [ of 25 % of entire ballots ] in Ohio. These Numberss obviously display a recoil against McCain for doing such statements as naming Pat Robertson forces of immorality. The Protestant elector is important in republican primaries since the most Republican of spiritual groups are white fundamentalist/evangelical Christians, followed by mainline white Christian, so Catholic and eventually Judaic ballots. Even when McCain played the Catholic card by usage of the Catholic elector qui vive phone calls in New York since Catholics made up a significant part of the primary electors but accordingly, their ballots did non differ much from other ballots on Super Tuesday. By rejecting Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell, McCain forfeited many Republican electors to Bush. The last clip the race card was a major issue was during John F. Kennedy s run but unlike McCain s brazen effort to weaken Bush by claiming that he would bow down to fundamentalists, Kennedy took stairss to do clear his independency of the church [ put frontward in ] an article published in Look in March 1959 in a house but non-threatening mode. As Jeff Greenfield of CNN claims If merely he had laid down his challenge to Christian conservativists as an entreaty for them to beef up their instance, alternatively of projecting it in personal footings, carrying those faith-based conservativists that he was their enemy, instead than an ally offering a fresh attack to their concerns” might he hold fared better in the Republican primaries.

Another major issue in this Republican competition was negative candidacy. The chief negative ad placed by McCain was The ad, which features McCain talking directly into the camera, makes a direct comparing between Bush & # 8217 ; s unfavorable judgment of McCain in his ads and President Clinton. McCain subsequently pulls the advertizement but Bush refuses to draw his negative ads claiming that his advertizements are non truly negative but are instead refuting the allegations made by the Senator. This was a major error on the portion of the Senator since Across widely changing events, scenes and individuals, positive experiences or positive facets of stimulations have been found to be less influential in the formation of judgements than are negative experiences or negatives facets of stimulation. McCain, who subsequently, switched to more positive ads, where he portrays himself as a Reagan conservative with a solid conservative record and while advisers recognize the effectivity of positive polispots they frequently remind campaigners that positive musca volitanss are merely non persuasive. By 1974, self styled mugwumps outnumbered Republicans 5 to 3, therefore In a universe where the bulk of electors are independent, the cardinal focal point for most advisers and their clients must be on making ads that can carry. Although a boomerang consequence may happen when a negative ad is perceived as being unjust or dishonest about none is seen with Bush s use of negative advertizements who claimed triumphs in South Carolina and New York, two provinces bombarded with an copiousness of negative ads aimed towards McCain.

The negative ad runs launched by Bush besides served to harm McCain in another mode. McCain s response to the negative ads led to bitter in-fighting amongst the two prima GOP rivals which led electors to believe that McCain is non a party uniter. This is a cardinal factor in the heads of Republican electors since about 6 out of 10 Republicans [ in South Carolina ] said they wanted a campaigner loyal to the party. McCain appears on telecasting shows such as NBC s Today show reprobating Bush for running negative ads against him alternatively of concentrating on the issues of the run. Rather than concentration on the issue of gun control, which one time once more rose due to the six twelvemonth old shot in Flint, Michigan, or recent instances of racial profiling by the constabulary, he appears contemptible and junior-grade by merely covering with the negative ads run against him. As Gene Johnson of the Boston Globe puts it:

By doing the presidential run excessively much about himself and about George W. Bush & # 8217 ; s petroleum attempts to oppress him, particularly in the month since his dramatic launch out of New Hampshire, McCain has lost a aureate chance to stop up into something that, as he says in his stump address, is greater than his ain opportunism.

This, excessively, causes him to release ballots to Bush since the negative runs non merely persuaded electors to back up Bush on election twenty-four hours but besides, by his ain mistake, lowered McCain s personality to a quibbling kid instead than a adult male who had been tough plenty to defy the conditions at Hanoi Hilton for about five and half old ages.

The personality component was besides a major function in the primaries since In a state basking peace abroad and unprecedented richness at place, with no compelling national issue, electors are expected to do their pick on character and personality. In New Hampshire, McCain rode high on the moving ridges of his legendary military record and his record as being the consecutive taw who was traveling to state you some things you want to hear and traveling to state you some things you don & # 8217 ; t want to hear, but ever traveling to state you the truth. & # 8221 ; John McCain won large non because New Hampshire swooned for his run finance reform, but because it loved the thought of voting for person who seems to be everything Clinton/Gore are non: honest, principled, incorruptible. But all this changed with the usage of the Catholic Voter Alert phone calls made in Michigan. The McCain cantonment at first denied doing such calls but subsequently acknowledged that they did, nevertheless they insisted that nil in the calls accused Bush of being anti-Catholic. This account had the leftovers of Clinton s rationalisation that unwritten sex International Relations and Security Network t sexual intercourse. But the Straight Talk Express has besides been thrown a few other curve balls before this peculiar incident. Others include McCain s stance on abortion, when asked: would you revoke Roe v. Wade? The reply was the usual standard yes until his interview with the San Francisco Chronicle in August he mentioned that he would non back up a abrogation of Roe v. Wade. These incompatibilities would non hold caused such an call to denounce McCain had it non been that, as Eddie Mahe ( GOP strategian ) points out: when you & # 8217 ; re running the sort of race he has run, based on character, your runing infinite is tighter than it is for most politicians. However, this harm could hold been rectified had McCain apologized. One of the chief attractive characteristics of Senator McCain is ability to recognize when he is incorrect, as can be seen in his book Faith of my Fathers where he apologise for perpetrating criminal conversation when married to his first married woman, etc. But as Greenfield provinces: If merely we & # 8217 ; d [ McCain Campaign ] been straight about that & # 8216 ; Catholic voter alert & # 8217 ; in Michigan, alternatively of dancing around the simple fact that we & # 8217 ; vitamin D paid for those telephone calls, giving the imperativeness a ground to project uncertainty on our & # 8220 ; straight talk & # 8221 ; promise. Consequently, more ballots are lost to Bush whose chief run issue was non his character. Contrarily, McCain should hold raised the character issue with Bush who has had a fly-by-night yesteryear with intoxicant and drugs and does non hold the distinguished military record that McCain has. This demand to be above junior-grade political relations ( but subsequently returning to it when negative ads are run against him ) cost Senator McCain dearly-won Republican ballots in an election where character and non issues are the head of public argument.

And eventually, another subscriber to the death of McCain s run is the deficiency of clip available to run in primaries that occurred after New Hampshire. McCain campaigned for 71 yearss and held 114 town meetings to hike his image at a clip when he was shadowed by Governor Bush and was fighting for national media attending. But this changed in South Carolina, where he merely had 18 yearss to change over the impulse gained from the New Hampshire conquering into another triumph in South Carolina. Surveies have shown that little, separate primaries maximize the ability of campaigners to do their ain statement to electors and since, at the point in clip, McCain s chief message was still his character, particularly his bravery to convey to the head of the Republican primary the issue of run reform, did non make as many electors as he would hold liked. He depended on mass media such as telecasting and wireless ads but that excessively, did non hold its full consequence due to the bombardment of negative ad runs placed by Bush. After the South Carolina primary, primaries were being held in more than one province on the same twenty-four hours. This meant that:

the larger the figure of primaries on any given twenty-four hours, the greater the figure of electors, and the larger the geographical spread, the less impression direction campaigner are able to make and the more the media take over. In this regard, Super Tuesday and any other front burden of the procedure increases the media s influence.

By the clip, Super Tuesday had rolled about, inquiries arose from the media of McCain s straight talk express and the national media focused on the acrimonious belligerencies that the GOP campaigners had for each other. Due to the big figure of provinces voting on Super Tuesday, McCain lacked the clip to adequately run in these provinces and the images portrayed by telecasting intelligence studies were non similar to the 1s exemplifying him as the war veteran with a no nonsensical attack in covering with the issues during the New Hampshire run. Therefore, McCain, yet once more failed to capture the Republican ballot as lacked the clip to make out to electors in a more personal mode.

Though there have been many errors committed by the McCain cantonment this is non to state that they didn Ts do certain things right. They brought an enthusiasm amongst immature and first clip electors, the like of which hasn T been seen since John F. Kennedy s command for the White House. And, McCain r4eached out to Democrats and mugwumps, an achievement that can non be claimed by the GOP presidential campaigners of the past two general elections and is an indispensable demand to win the general election in November. His run brought a message more trim to the center instead than the far right land captured by Bush, therefore, guaranting a broader general elector base. But, however, the mistakes committed by the run such as non making out earlier to the republican elector by concentrating on issues that are non cardinal to the nucleus Republican party s values, denouncing the Christian Right ( particularly in the Southern provinces ) and the inquiries raised about his character all served to swing the ballots towards Governor George Bush and therefore, led to the death of his run.

34a