J.D. Salinger Vs. S.E. Hinton Essay, Research Paper

Imagine this: you write a novel, and it is banned. All that difficult work down the drain. To J.D. Salinger and S.E. Hinton this is non a figment of their imaginativeness. This IS world. Salinger? s Catcher in The Rye and Hinton? s The Foreigners have been banned in many school territories and public libraries. These two mistreated novels, each of the writer? s most celebrated, are cogent evidence of their literary illustriousness. Their illustriousness can be found in their literary manner. Although these writers are similar in some facets, they are dissimilar in others.

The first manner to compare and contrast Hinton and Salinger is to discourse them as human existences. Jerome David Salinger was born on January 1, 1919, in New York City. He is the boy of a Judaic male parent and an Irish female parent, the 2nd of two kids. He graduated from Valley Forge Military Academy in 1936, where his I.Q. was recorded as 115. In the following few old ages he attended periodically a figure of colleges, including New York University, without finishing a plan for a grade. In 1937-38 he made a brief visit to Austria and Poland in the service of his male parent? s meat-import concern. Shortly after, he found his manner into a short-story authorship category taught by Whit Burnett Columbia. In 1940, at the age of 21, he published his first narrative, ? The Young Folks? in Burnett? s Story Magazine. Eleven old ages subsequently, Salinger published Catcher in The Rye, his most celebrated novel. In 1955, Salinger married Claire Douglas, and settled in Cornish, New Hampshire ; they had a girl in 1955 and a boy in 1960. By the age of 17, Susan Eloise Hinton was a published writer. She was born on April 22, 1949, in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Since the storyteller in The Outsiders was a male child, Hinton? s publishing houses suggested that she print under the name of S.E. Hinton ; they feared their readers wouldn? t regard a? macho? narrative written by a adult female. Today Hinton says, ? I don? T head holding two individualities ; in fact, I like maintaining the author portion separate in some ways. And since my alter self-importance is clearly a 15-year-old male child, holding an auctorial ego that doesn? t suggest a gender is all right with me. ? Hinton attended college at the University of Tulsa, analyzing to be a instructor. ? I don? Ts have the nervus or physical staying power to learn, ? she says. ? I did my pupil instruction, but I couldn? Ts leave the childs and their jobs behind me ; I? vitamin D go place and worry about them. I think people who are good instructors do one of the most of import occupations there is ; I can? t praise them extremely enough. ? While go toing college Hinton met David Inhofe, who became her hubby in 1970. They have a boy named Nick.

The 2nd avenue of comparing is their plot lines, which involve subjects of anomic young person. Hinton? s The Outsiders is about a male child named Ponyboy. He has a pack named the Greasers. Ponyboy? s parents died in

a auto clang, so he doesn? Ts have any parents, he lives with his two older brothers. Ponyboy? s best friend Johnny killed a pack member named Bob in the other pack ( the Socs ) . The other pack, the Socs, fight Ponyboy and his pack. ( This is when Johnny kills Bob. ) Ponyboy and Johnny run off, go on a train, and happen a church when they get off. They dye each other? s hair so they aren? T recognizable. At the terminal of the narrative, Johnny dies in the infirmary from salvaging some childs in a fire. Since Johnny died Dally, one of the Socs, was truly huffy and went to a shop and stole some money. Dally called Ponyboy? s brother and said, ? Help me! The bulls are coming! ? Then Dally ran and was caught by the bulls. He shot at the bulls, and so the bulls shot him dead. ( This narrative seems sort of distorted and? jerky? , but it? s really a great book. I love it! ) Salinger? s foremost novel, The Catcher in The Rye, was an immediate success. Narrated in the first individual by Holden Caulfield, a 16-year-old male child who is being dismissed from his prep school for academic failure, this narrative relates the male child? s escapades during three yearss entirely in New York City. Holden attempts to do contact with a figure of people, but is disillusioned when he finds them flawed by lip service, inhuman treatment, or ugliness. The lone individual in whom he can believe is his younger sister Phoebe, who finally persuades him non to run off from place. Throughout the narrative, Holden imagines his ain decease. For illustration, after the degrading incident with a hotel procurer and a cocotte, Holden provinces, ? What I truly felt like, though, was perpetrating self-destruction. I felt like leaping out the window. I likely would? ve done it, excessively if I? d been certain person? vitamin D screen me up every bit shortly as I landed. ? In both narratives, the chief character dealt with decease often.

A concluding comparing standards is literary repute of the writers. J.D. Salinger? s work was received more enthusiastically by post-World War II American young person than that of any other author. S.E. Hinton? s work marked the beginning of a new sort of pragmatism in books written for the immature grownup market. Both writers are known for composing chef-d’oeuvres.

In decision, it can be seen that J.D. Salinger and S.E. Hinton have similarities every bit good as unsimilarities. Their diverse manners contributed to their literary illustriousness. What a calamity that the plants of these literary greats have been banned. It? s no admiration that these two writers live their lives in privacy. I would excessively!

* hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ramdomhouse.com/teachersbdd/sehi.html ( 12-1-99 )

*http: //www.shsu.edu/~eng_ajm/indextwt.htm # ThatWasThen

*http: //www.edupaperback.org/authorbios/hintonse.html

*http: //falcon.jmu.edu/~ramseyil/hinton.htm

*Grolier Educational Encyclopedia Americana 1998 ( CD ROM )

*American Writers, 1974 Vol.3 ( CD ROM )