Mentor/Protege Relationship Essay, Research Paper
Danny Frank Myth and Mind 413 Final, Part 1 Mr. Rosenberg East vs. West ; The Mentor/Protege Relationship Mentors have been teaching their proteges since the morning of clip. From male parent to boy, and female parent to girl, fables and accomplishments have been passed through the coevalss this manner. Yet, the manner information is passed tends to differ from one civilization to the following. This can clearly be seen when comparing the literature of eastern and western civilizations. Siddhartha, by Herman Hesse, and The Woman Warrior, by Maxine Hong Kingston, demo how in the eastern civilizations, wise mans teach their proteges by merely stating the what is the right manner, while Iron John, by the Grimm brothers, and Into Woods, by Bill Roorbach, demo how wise mans lead by illustration in the western civilizations. In Siddhartha, the immature Siddhartha and his friend Govinda meet a wise religious adult male named Gotama. Gotama teaches the male childs of the Buddha and the four truths. While his linguistic communication at times my seem cryptic and poetic, Gotama is obviously declaiming what he has found to be true in order to educate the male childs. While in the terminal it is merely Govinda who takes Gotama+s word to bosom, both male childs clearly understand the thoughts that he was seeking to learn. The Woman Warrior besides illustrates this bluntness between instructor and pupil. When Maxine was a kid, her female parent cut her lingua. Maxine thought this had to make with a Chinese adage that said |a ready lingua is an evil tongueX. Yet, when asked, Maxine+s mother clearly explains that her lingua was non cut to maintain her quite, but so that it could be freed and able to larn other linguistic communications. Without a enlistment, Maxine understood what her female parent was seeking to learn her. While wise mans and proteges of the E seem to be really clear in their relationship, in the west their nexus seems to be a spot more |unspokenX. In the Grimms+ fairy narrative Iron John, a wild adult male of T
he woods, Iron John, takes a immature prince under his wing. In order to learn him that to lift to the top, one must first hit stone underside, Iron John instructs him to do certain nil falls into his aureate pool. The male child fails at the assignment, and Iron John kicks him banishes him from the comfort and safety of his forest place. Subsequently, the male child eventually rises to get married the girl of a affluent male monarch. The male child ne’er knew that Iron John kicked him out of the forest in order to make his true fate, because Iron John ne’er came Forth and told him. Yet, the terminal consequence would hold still been the same anyhow.
Another illustration of mute mentoring can be seen in the instance of Bill Roorbach. In his essay, Into Woods, Roorbach describes how his love for woodworking and other skilled trades conflicted with the outlook for him to travel to college and win. The footing for his love of woodworking stemmed from working alongside his male parent. Although really an oil company executive, when at place Roorbach+s male parent spent his clip as a fix-it adult male. Alternatively of holding the desire to go a affluent man of affairs, Roorbach learned to go a carpenter by working with his pa, even though it was ne’er something the two talked about. In this manner, Roorbach+s father set an illustration that Roorbach followed for old ages to come. Clearly, the eastern thought of the mentor/protege relationship is easier to understand. By coming out in the unfastened with the thoughts needed to be learned, the wise man can expeditiously pass on what it is that the protege must larn. However, the western manner of insurgent mentoring could perchance be better in the manner it disguises the existent lesson. Otherwise, the pupil might non desire to follow along with what the instructor has planned. Either manner you choose, the terminal consequence will most probably be the same, so it seem that the specifying factor of the Mentor/Protege relationship comes from whichever civilization is represented.
