Movies Vs. Books Essay, Research Paper

Air, nutrient, H2O, shelter, and fire are of import elements of life for human bings. Without those elements worlds could non perchance survive. Those are the obvious 1s, but have you of all time thought of something else that you couldn? t live without? When you answered that inquiry did telecasting, or books come to mind? If they didn? T so believe once more. Entertainment is a really of import portion of our being, particularly in our civilization. Without amusement, whether it be single or with a group, worlds could non remain sane, hence could non last. There are many types of amusement. Worlds, since Adam and Eve have been entertaining themselves in all kinds of different ways. Equally simple as playing with sticks and rocks, and every bit complex as winging F-16 contending jets ; we need amusement. Two of the most popular signifiers of amusement today is watching televison, and reading books.

Reading and composing is one of the oldest signifiers of communications. Throughout the ages narratives have been past down from coevals to coevals through word of oral cavity, and through the coming of paper ; books. One hundred old ages ago there was no wireless, no autos, and no telecasting. They entertained themselves in different ways so we do today. When they finished their work, alternatively of plopping themselves on the sofa with the distant control, they either sat down with their household and talked, or they read. They read verse forms, enigma novels, science-fiction novels, love affair novels, and so on. People one hundred old ages ago read much more than we do today, so does that do them smarter than we are today?

When I sit down someplace to read a book, I have to acquire prepared. I have to be in a quiet ambiance, I have to be in the temper to read, and I must be prepared to sit down and read for a clip period of at least an hr. If I? m non able to make any one of those things when I start to read, so I will lose my concentration, and I will halt reading. I find it much easier merely to turn on the telecasting, happen a channel that I like, and watch what? s on. It doesn? Ts take as much mental concentration that it does to read a fresh so it does to watch a film. Does that perchance intend that you learn more when you read?

I have two illustrations to seek and happen out if that inquiry is true or non. The two illustrations are the dealingss between the book and the film of? Snow Falling on Cedars? , and the other is? The Perfect Storm? . I believe those are both good illustrations to compare between the other because they are both about decease and drowning, and both are set in bantam fishing small towns. First I will speak about? Snow Falling on Cedars. ?

The novel? Snow Falling on Cedars? by David Guterson is a narrative about love, decease, perfidy, fraudulence, love affair, and many more adjectives that I can? t think of right now. It takes topographic point in a bantam fishing small town on an island off of the Washington seashore. The novel is four 100 and 60 pages long, and it has a reasonably complicated secret plan. The secret plan frequently moves back and Forth from present tense to past tense. It takes topographic point during WWII so that is a major factor in the clip line of the secret plan. WWII is most definite when we move the Nipponese Americans out of their places and into concentration cantonments. A white local male child named Ishmael and a Nipponese miss named Hatsue autumn in love without allowing either of their household? s know about their relationship. But when the Americans take Hatsue and her household from place Ishmael can? t base being off from his love, and he writes a missive to Hatsue and her female parent finds it. When Hatsue? s female parent finds out she bands Hatsue from seeing Ishmael, and Hatsue begins to recognize that it their relationship would ne’er work out. Even though their relationship ends, they still ever think about each other, particularly Ishmael who will ever love Hatsue.

Ishmael and Hatsue? s relationship is explained in a good part of the book. And whenever their relationship is explained it is being presented in the past tense. So a big part of the novel is written in past tense. The other parts of the novel is in the present tense which is taking topographic point largely in a tribunal room where there is a instance taking topographic point about a possible homicide of a fishermen out at sea. The asleep fisherman is Carl Heine. The suspect is Kabuo Miyamoto, a Nipponese American who had agreements to purchase a portion of Carl Heine? s strawberry farm. Kabuo Miyamoto is Hatsue? s hubby. All grounds leads to Kabuo as being guilty in the slaying Carl Heine, but information from an improbable beginning proves him guiltless. The information came from a juryman, Ishmael Chambers ; Hatsue? s child-hood love.

The writer of the book did an first-class occupation with item, suspense, and demoing in item, the events taking up to the artlessness of Kabuo. When I was reading the book I was bored with the subdivisions of Hatsue and Ishmael. I thought those scenes lagged and weren? t really exciting. What I didn? Ts know when I wasn? Ts finished with the book is that those scenes of Hatsue and Ishmael were so of import to the result of the test and of the whole narrative. When I was finished with the book I thought of the scenes of Hatsue and Ishmael, and I realized how of import those scenes ended up being to the result. Even though while I was reading the book I thought some parts were tiring, when I was done reading I understood the significance of those parts and I couldn? t imagine those parts non be included. The same was true with the film of? Snow Falling on Cedars? .

I think the manager did the best he could, even though it wasn? t a moderately good occupation, with the passage from developing this film from the book. I believe merely from the secret plan of the book that it wasn? t an easy occupation in doing the passage from the book to the large screen. When I watched the film I had already read the book so I already knew what the secret plan of the book was traveling to be, but my parents who watched it with me had no hint what the secret plan was because I didn? T state them anything, and they had non read the book. My parents shortly became really bored with the film. They said it was really slow and dull. While those were their actions it wasn? T mine. I enjoyed the film. It was reasonably easy for me to follow the film, and I was really cognizant of the state of affairss. There were many parts of the film that I had to state my ma what was go oning and where we were. Even though this was my first clip watching the film, I was moving like the instructor, and my other was the pupil because I had some experience with the book and my female parent had non read it. If I didn? T read the book before I watched the film I would hold likely been merely every bit lost as my female parent was, and I would? ve shut the film off, or travel do something else. The same was true when I was reading the novel for the first clip.

If it wasn? T for me demoing up to all the categories, and take parting in the treatments we had on the book, I know I wouldn? Ts have read beyond page fifty by myself. Equally shortly as the narrative changed puting to Hatsue and Ishmael as kids, I would? ve lost all involvement in the book if it hadn? T been for the treatments we had in category. The same I think is true for watching the film. If I didn? T read the book with the fullest apprehension of it that I learned in category, I would? ve ne’er have gained involvement in the film. The film did travel truly slow at times, merely like the book ; at the same parts as a affair of fact.

When doing a large screen image from a novel the manager has many options to see. First, he has to make up one’s mind on which parts of the novel he wants to set into his movie. Since a typical novel is about four hundred pages long the manager can? t put all of that into the movie or else the film will be 10 hours long. And since the normal mean attending span for a human is around the two hr grade, everyone will be disinterested in/sleeping before the film is a 3rd of the manner finished. Because of our short attending spans, the manager must del

ete a important part out of the novel, and still portray the chief secret plan and subject of the novel. The manager of the film? Snow falling on Cedars? did a superb occupation in remaining with the secret plan of the book without altering it much, particularly since he had a book with a hard secret plan to work with in the first topographic point. I noticed that the scenes were significantly shortened in the film compared to the book, but that was merely due to the manager? s clip restraints. The manager besides played around with the order of the secret plan excessively which I found quiet interesting. For illustration, in the book, flashbacks of Ishmael in war was first, and so was Kabuo? s war experience, where in the film it was the other manner around. The manager besides changed the secret plan around where in the beginning of the film he showed Carl Heine in the shadows working on his boat and seting up the lantern. The book starts right out with everyone in the courtroom waiting for the start of the test. I think the manager wanted the viewing audiences to acquire a speedy apprehension of the scene of the film. If he started out in a courtroom the viewing audiences would hold no hint where the film is taking topographic point.

I think it was an outstanding pick for the manager to utilize a tinted lens on the camera for this film. It gives us a sense of an old-style film, and since this took topographic point in the nineteen-forties, that is appropriate. It besides puts us in the right temper for this movie. This is a romantic play with non a whole batch of action happening. If it were to be a regular lens with regular lighting, I think it tends to set us in a temper where there must be a batch of action, because a batch of illuming stands the image out and puts it right in our face. The green tinted lens doesn? Ts have that same consequence. It keeps the image at a comfy distance off, and it puts us in merely the right temper for this film. Another film that I believe has great usage of particular effects, in a wholly different manner is? The Perfect Storm? .

The manager for? The Perfect Storm? chose non to utilize a tinted lens for shot because he wanted the viewing audiences to be in the movie, and see the same action the histrions are acquiring. This film is a pure action-drama that puts the audience slap tap in the center of the secret plan. That is different so? Snow Falling on Cedars? because in that film the audience is really sing and sing, but non a portion of the movie. The scenes of the two movies are similar. They both take topographic point in little fishing small towns ; one on San Piedro Island, and one in Gloucester Massachusetts. One takes topographic point in the Pacific Ocean in the 19 mid-fortiess and 1950ss, and one takes topographic point in the Atlantic Ocean in 19 ninety-one.

The effects in the film of? The Perfect Storm? are unbelievable. The manager makes it seem like the moving ridges are winging off the screen right into your life room. In the film, we get to cognize a small about the fishermen? s households and where they all come from, but non much. I think that was the program of the manager because of class, the fishermen die at the terminal of the film, and since this was more of an action film, he didn? T want the viewing audiences to acquire over inactive and filled with enviousness when they died. I thought the book was much different so the film.

The largest difference between? The Perfect Storm? and? Snow Falling on Cedars? is that? The Perfect Storm? was based on a true narrative. In that instance, the novel of? The Perfect Storm? was filled much more with facts, and the existent life styles of fishermen. The book went into item on how tough the life of a fishermen was, and it went into great item on how to swordfish. It talked about the crew of the swordfish boat, how to angle, and how much money can they gain on a normal expedition out to sea. Other than the occupation itself, the book went into item on the life styles of Gloucester fishermen, particularly of the crew that was portion of the Andrea Gail. Since the manager of the film? The Perfect Storm? had the same clip guidelines as that of the manager of? Snow Falling on Cedars? , he had to go forth the inside informations of the life styles of the fishermen out, and concentrate more of them being caught in the storm because that is where the most action is.

One thing that I wish the manager added into the film that the book contained was a portion about submerging. In the novel the writer went into great item on what it is like to submerge. He interviewed people who had the unfortunate experience of about submerging. One individual was found after being submerged in the H2O for 15 proceedingss. He was so revived, and he lives to state his narrative. I wish the manager of the movie showed one of the crew in item drowning because I found it interesting. The ground I believe he didn? T because it is excessively ghastly and difficult for some people to bear which I understand.

The book ne’er went into any item on how the Andrea Gail went down in the storm because no 1 knows or else the crew would likely still be with us today. The writer mentioned the last transmittals between the Andrea Gail and another swordfish boat, and he talks about what they were likely believing, but that? s it. In order to do a film out of the book though, the manager had to add a wholly made up stoping as to how the Andrea Gail went down to delight the audience. I think he did a good occupation with that, although I think the portion in the terminal where the captain of the boat had a opportunity to acquire out of the boat but doesn? T because he is to honorable to his ship is a poke of *censored* . I don? T attention how honest I am to anything if I have a opportunity to populate I will seek my hardest to acquire into a better state of affairs.

Any manager who volunteers themselves to be portion of a movie based on a book is inquiring for a challenge. As a species, us worlds need action ; we have to be making something all the clip. That is why our attending span is so short, and that is why we give managers a difficult clip. If our attending span lasted 10 hours so the managers would hold an easy occupation change overing a book to a film. Just travel by whatever is in the book, and follow the book chapter by chapter. But of class our attending span International Relations and Security Network? t about that long so that leaves it up to the manager to go forth out some things here, and add other things here. All in all though, I believe the managers of both? Snow Falling on Cedars? and? The Perfect Storm? did an first-class occupation in change overing a novel to the large screen with what they had to work with.

The reply to my inquiry in the beginning of my paper is yes. You can larn more in reading a book so you can in watching a film. It? s all due to our short attending span that I have discussed so much about. I? m non stating you wear? T learn anything while watching a film. In fact, with the right narrative, and the right manager, you can larn a batch more than in reading some of these books that are out at that place now. Since much more item ( a.k.a information ) can be put into a novel than a film we frequently get much more out of reading so watching television. I do believe that some twenty-four hours that might alter. If we can happen out a manner to lengthen our attending span, I believe that we can acquire much more out of watching a film so a book. They say you can analyze better if you write down what your perusal, so read it to yourself, so state it out loud, and so hold person read it to you. While reading all you can make is read it, and possibly have person read it to you. But if we can happen a manner of amusement that can allow us utilize all of our techniques of analyzing without allowing us know that we are really analyzing, it will do everyone on this planet smarter, and so who knows what will go on. What I? m stating is that if we can integrate reading and watching a movie together, that will be the most rational signifier of amusement we could perchance hold. But for now all I can urge is to change your signifiers of amusement. Have the best of both universes. Read when you have some free clip during the twenty-four hours after work, and so travel to the films on the weekend!