Owen Vs. Metallica Essay, Research Paper

Owen and Metallica: Worlds Apart but Message The Same

For my paper, I chose to compare and contrast Wilfred Owen s verse form, & # 8220 ; Dulce Et Decorum Est & # 8221 ; and Metallica s vocal & # 8220 ; One. & # 8221 ; Although Owen died before the members of Metallica were even born, they both portion the same message in these two verse forms. That message is a simple but of import one: War isn t glorious ; it s dirty and barbarous. They go about acquiring the point across really otherwise, but that doesn Ts take off from the similarities that they portion.

Owen was a 20 twelvemonth old when he was contending in World War I. He was twice wounded in conflict and he wrote his verse forms, non to be a good poet, but alternatively to demo the universe war through his eyes. His verse form opened the eyes so ; the force depicted in his verse form shocked the populace to attending. It wasn T boulder clay after his decease in conflict that most of his verse forms were published, along with his book of verse forms, & # 8220 ; Lifes of the Poets. & # 8221 ;

Metallica is a stone group made up of James Hetfield, Lars Ulrich, Kirk Hammett, and Jason Newsted. This vocal was written in respects to the Vietnam War, or should I say in protest of it. It uses metaphysical amour propres to turn to the mental torment a Vietnam Veteran is sing after coming home from the war: hurts and all. This was Metallica s foremost & # 8220 ; large & # 8221 ; hit in stone music.

In Owen s verse form it starts with a scene of some soldiers who are on their manner back to cantonment after being on the forepart for who knows how long. & # 8220 ; Bent double, like old mendicants under sacks. & # 8221 ; He describes the immature male childs as old mendicants to demo how the war had prematurely aged them to adulthood. As they are processing off from the conflict field, off from the battle, they are beaten and bloody ; some even walk on a stub, because they have lost a pes. & # 8220 ; Drunk with weariness ; & # 8221 ; the soldiers were so tired they couldn t even walk directly, they walked like rummies. Then out of apparently nowhere they were fired upon, but non with slugs, with gas: mustard gas most likely. As Owen tickers, & # 8220 ; though the brumous window glasss and thick green visible radiation, & # 8221 ; a friend, a companion of his drowns in the gas, and there is nil that he can make.

Owen goes on to depict how the male child looks on the waggon as they march behind it watching as the male child coughing up his ain blood, & # 8220 ; with every jar & # 8221 ; of the waggon. Then Owen sums up this narrative with a moral: & # 8220 ; My friend, you would

non state with such high gusto to kids ardent for some despairing glorification, the old prevarication: Dulce et Decorum est pro patria mori.” The “old lie” is a quotation mark used by Owen from the Latin poet Horace, significance ; “It is a sweet and fitting thing to decease for one s country.”

Metallica doesn Ts have any existent warfront narratives, but alternatively they have the originative ability to paint a image in vocal of what is traveling on in the head of a Vietnam Veteran. They use the line, & # 8220 ; Now that the war is through with me. & # 8221 ; this illustrates merely how used the veteran is. It doesn Ts say & # 8220 ; now that I m done with the war, & # 8221 ; alternatively it gives the war the control, non the ground forcess or the states in it. I think this is such a true statement. Once a war has begun it takes control, it takes control of the economic system, the authorities, and the soldiers contending in it. Over and over once more the veteran cries out to God for aid. This obviously shows how much agony the vet is truly in. Too many times in existent life, I personnally make the error of merely traveling to God when we have tried everything else and it has all failed ; this line depicts the anguish that the veteran is traveling through. For him to name out to God, the hurting he was traveling through must hold been really terrible.

This veteran is clearly merely populating because of the life-support system that he is hooked to, & # 8220 ; fed through the tubing that sticks in me. & # 8221 ; But in the same stanza, he asks for person to & # 8220 ; cut this life off from me. & # 8221 ; The war has taken all he has except his life. How cruel is that? He is down and self-destructive. Metallica wrote this vocal, I believe, to floor the populace to attending, merely like Owen did his. Their message? The same as Owen s every bit good, to halt the foolish belief that deceasing for one s state is baronial and glorious.

Both of these pieces used such tones as metaphors and similes. Owen s metrical construction was an ababcdcd construction, while Metallica used a really loose aaaa, bbbb construction. Both construction are really effectual in allowing the me have a certain form of idea. The construction allowed me to concentrate on the topic of the verse form while I was reading/listening.

Owen s War Poetry was likely more effectual than Metallica s vocal, non because of the content or the message. In Metallica s vocal, the loud, hard-pounding music distracts the hearer from the true purpose of the wordss. At the same clip, I believe that both were really indispensable and relevant to the cause.