A

The texts in subdivision A focal point on decorative surgery on adolescents. Write a paper ( 700-1000 words ) in which you answer the undermentioned inquiries. Answer the inquiries individually.

1. Give an lineation of the assorted positions on plastic surgery for adolescents. which are presented in texts 1 and 2 2. How dies Valerie Ulene prosecute the reader in the topic in text 1? Exemplify your reply with illustrations from the text. 3. Taking your get downing point in text 3. discuss whether decorative surgery on adolescents should be banned.

1.

Both given texts. “Plastic surgery for teens” by Valerie Ulene and “Seeking Self-Esteem Through Surgery” by Camille Sweeny. hold really similar positions on plastic surgery for adolescents in America. They both hold the position that adolescents are pressured by set beauty criterions. which are displayed by media and other industries.

In the first text “Plastic surgery for teens” Valerie Ulene. the writer and a specializer for preventative surgery in the US. says that America’s adolescents feel the demand to undergo plastic surgery because they think of the beauty criterions as the given norm and want to accomplish those norms. Ulene is of the sentiment that plastic surgery shouldn’t be the alternate to diets and exercising. because most teens are really impatient and alter their sentiments rapidly. so they might repent their pick shortly after. She believes teens will obtain a better position on themselves. as they grow older and travel through the procedure of turning up. It’s non wholly unwise to acquire a plastic surgery. harmonizing to Valerie Ulene. she thinks some adolescents. who have had the want for a long clip. should hold the chance. but sooner when they are lawfully aloud to subscribe consent. until so parents and physicians should find whether or non the adolescent should turn to a surgeon’s knife.

The 2nd text “Seeking Self-Esteem Through Surgery” by Camille Sweeny. the writer is of the reasonably same sentiment as given in the first text. Sweeny besides believes that the turning figures of teenage plastic surgery emanate from unapproachable beauty criterions. She quotes critics who think that the turning figure of fictile surgery. particularly among adolescent misss. stems from the fact. striplings have low ego regard and because plastic surgery has become easy to entree. Sweeny besides thinks a batch of adolescents are incognizant of the long-run effects. like hurting or follow-up surgeries. She feels it is of import to dispute the given criterions and prophesy different 1s. besides it is of import to accept one’s ain visual aspect.

2.

Valerie Ulene engages the reader by stating about herself and how she “disliked [ her ] nose as a adolescent would be an understatement” ( l. 1 ) . this manner the reader feels like she is honorable and respectable. Furthermore she uses pronouns like “I” ( l. 2. l. 3 ) to do clear that she states her ain sentiment. Ulene besides makes usage of modern footings like “getting it “done”” ( l. 3 ) and “fixed” ( l. 62 ) and by making that she seems closer to the adolescents. whom she wants to make. Ulene entreaties to logos and carry the audience by ground. an illustration of this is “The American Society of Plastic Surgeons estimates that more than 330. 000 striplings ( … ) ” ( l. 6 ) where she uses informations from a respected American establishment and therefore the reader trusts her and her sentiment and she seems believable.

Expressive adjectives like “ridiculous” ( l. 17 ) or “tremendous” ( l. 60 ) underscore her statement on plastic surgery or beauty criterions. Subsequently on in the text she makes usage of poignancy to appeal to the readers’ emotions and convert them to believe in her statement by making an emotional response. “With a 14-year-old girl of my ain. I recognize how hard that [ stating no to plastic surgery ] can be. While I’d like to believe that I’d dissuade – if non forbid – her from holding decorative work done” . ( ll. 58-59 ) With this quote the reader empathizes with Ulene. because it’s now a batch more apprehensible why she’s against plastic surgery on adolescents. and in the following paragraph she uses another illustration from her life where she diminishes the want for plastic surgery by stating “as far as my ain olfactory organ goes. I’ve ne’er truly grown to love it. I have grown used to it. nevertheless. and have no declinations that it was ne’er fixed” ( ll. 61-62 ) .

3.

“If they aren’t old plenty to subscribe their ain surgical consent for a medically necessary process. so they shouldn’t be able to bring on their parents to make it for decorative surgery which is a personal. subjective. value-based determination. non a determination of medical necessity. ” – Dr. Pete Costantino

Harmonizing to this quotation mark. the prohibition of decorative surgery for adolescents is a good thought. The subject of plastic and decorative surgery has been unfastened for a batch of argument. The inquiry whether it should be banned or non bears more than one job and can be viewed from different sides. The chief inquiry is though. where a medically necessary process terminals and becomes decorative surgery?

On the one manus. there is the job of the promoted unapproachable beauty norms. which adolescents are exposed to everyday. These norms make some adolescents believe that their characteristics are ugly or an abnormalcy. but they are largely wholly normal. A general prohibition of decorative surgery could assist them rethink the position on their organic structures. Besides. a batch of adolescents are really impatient. and if they don’t have entree to these sorts of surgeries. they are forced to wait and possibly they’ll rethink their determination.

In contrast to this. some adolescents are so unbearably unhappy with their characteristics that they don’t travel to school. don’t interact socially or are confronted with strong-arming from their schoolmates. If decorative surgery is prohibited for citizens under 18 old ages. they don’t have any opportunity of betterment in their lives. Often. parents have really different ethical motives and strong beliefs than striplings. and wouldn’t understand their child’s battle. and in the long tally the stripling is the 1 who has to populate with the given seventh cranial nerve or physical characteristics.

All in all. I am merely partially for a general prohibition of plastic surgery for bush leagues. I think there should be a enfranchisement that the individual undergoing plastic surgery is wholly cognizant of the effects the process will hold and that this individual has considered positive and negative effects of this determination. What I don’t agree with is that the authorities decides what distinguishes necessary medical surgery from decorative surgery. It’s non ever seeable if the individual needs this surgery or non. there are frequently mental jobs linked to the pick that is made.

Wordss: 963 ( without quotation mark )

1 ) Subsequently on in the text she makes usage of In diesem Satz war ein Kongruenzfehler. denn in der 3. P remarkable “she” mess dem Verb ein “s” hinzugefugt werden. 2 ) By making that she seems closer to the adolescents. whom she wants to make. Hier muss “whom” verwendet werden. district attorney Es sich auf das Praposition “to” bezieht. 3 ) Nachstes mal werde ich in meiner Outline darauf achten. keine bis wenig Fluchtigkeitsfehler Zu machen. um meine Sprache zu verbessern. Auch dice grammatischen Strukturen mochte ich mehr beachten. so dass sie komplexer. vielfaltiger und korrekt Sind. Auch von dem Inhalt her mochte ich versuchen ein wenig mehr auf Standpunkte einzugehen dice ich eventuell nicht ALSs wichtig empfinde. Um den Text leichter lesbar Zu machen. versuche ich alle dargestellten Haltungen klarzustellen und genau Zu erlautern. Beim zitieren versuche ich nachstes mal noch mehr auf das Integrieren in den Text Zu achten. damit er flie?ender Zu lesen wird.