The Caine Mutiny: Measuring The Performance Of A Government Essay, Research Paper

The Caine Mutiny

Measuring the Performance of a Government

Governments are an indispensable and of import portion to our mundane life, and without, there would be no control or leading. Governments are sanctioned to represent and systematize the interrelatednesss of the people with their divisional bounds, the dealingss of the people of the community as a whole, and the agreements of the community with other political entities. In the film, & # 8220 ; The Caine Mutiny & # 8221 ; , a signifier of authorities dramas an of import function to everybody aboard the ship. There were certain adversities with the constellation of the authorities, and in this instance, the authorities was the captain. Although the captain didn T go straight against the Naval Regulations, the crew thought that he was incapable of keeping this place as captain. With all of this occurrence, it was hard for the crewmans aboard the ship to appreciate the signifier of authorities and their leader.

The fundamental law for many states, hold the regulations ( may be written, or non written ) to which a authorities must obey. In this scenario, the Naval Regulations were intended to be followed upon and consented to. If a authorities is carry throughing its basic maps, so it is decently following the fundamental law, but if it isn t resulting the fundamental law, so the cardinal intents aren t being achieved. Within the fundamental law, there is power granted to impeach the leader if he/she is non implementing their primary services. In the film, we see captain Queeg as one who is incompetent of accomplishing his occupation as the leader. Captain Queeg can be easy compared with Charles III male monarch of England during the Revolutionary War. He was old, and powerful, and with authorization, but besides incorrect. Captain s new place angered many crewmans aboard the old conflict ship with his strict and reserved idiosyncrasies, and the manner he handled many state of affairss gave the crewmans fair ground to be easy infuriated. Overall Queeg portrayed a really ineffectual leader as caput of the authorities on the ship.

There are many possible hazards that one can come upon if they decide to alter authoritiess. There is ever the hazard of a failed authorities which could be at the worst disadvantage to anyone and everyone. Once a authorities fails, it can easy be trampled over

and picked upon by another state. The power can be lost by everyone in their state and can be hard to derive back. The alteration in authoritiess can besides consequence the people of the state, because it will most probably be at a disadvantage to some people because non everyone is easy satisfied. The support of people in a state can readily be lost and gone everlastingly.

One of the crewmans, Stillwell, was faced with a hard state of affairs when he was given beliing orders by captain Queeg and officer Maryk. Stillwell opted to take Maryk s orders, because he evidently thought that he was more of an effectual leader. Officer Maryk thought that Queeg was non following the Naval Regulations and felt that he had the power as stated in the fundamental law to catch captain Queeg s place. Even when taken to tribunal, officer Maryk was found non guilty of what he had done.

In today s universe, we see states set uping new authoritiess. They can be either at an advantage or disadvantage to their state, depending upon the alteration. An illustration of 1 that has had positive consequences would be that of East Germany. Before their alteration, they were keeping a communist authorities, but soon with West Germany they now hold a federal republic authorities. This has helped get down the diminishing of the Communist authoritiess and a definite advantage. Besides in Russia, although they aren t wholly non-communist, they are going more of a democratic society. The Cuban Prime Minister, Fidel Castro, has shown how a alteration in authorities can give negative consequences. Castro seized power when the authorities of Fulgencio Batista collapsed, and he openly embraced communism. His absolutism has shown no grounds of a successful authorities and in bend has shown hapless effects.

Governments of all withhold many and assorted types. What may work for one state, may ne’er work for another. There is truly no 1 to state what type of authorities is right and what type is incorrect, it s what works best for each state. However, it s unfortunate that there are states that have to cover with immoral leaders who make the incorrect picks and determinations. As learned in & # 8220 ; The Caine Mutiny & # 8221 ; , there is power given to do a alteration. Although it may non ever be the right thing to make, it will decidedly give a acquisition experience and may assist model the authorities to a more successful type.