Birthmark Essay, Research Paper

Originator: Copywork Staff English:

Georgians transmutation 2000-07-06

In? The Birthmark, ? by Nathaniel Hawthorne, Georgiana? s futile effort to be flawless by collaborating in her ain slaying doesn? t make her any wiser, particularly because such a forfeit does non gain her intimacy with her hubby. The character of Georgiana epitomizes the virtuousnesss upheld by the conventions of her clip ; she is beautiful, docile and has no aspirations of her ain other than to do her hubby happy. In add-on to this evident perfect brotherhood is a & # 8220 ; remarkable grade, profoundly interwoven, as it were, with the texture and substance of her face & # 8221 ; ( Hawthorne 11 ) . The nevus is otherwise interpreted by all. Initially Georgiana thinks of the nevus, as? a appeal, ? and Aylmer knows non? whether to term [ the nevus ] a defect or a beauty. . . ? ( Hawthorne 11 ) . Most individuals of her ain sex refers it as? the bloody manus, ? that? Quite destroy ( s ) the consequence of Georgiana? s beauty. . . ? ( Hawthorne 11 ) . While her supporters? were won? T to state that some faery at her birth-hour had laid her bantam manus upon the baby? s cheek, and left this impress [ the nevus ] at that place in item of the charming gifts that were to give her such sway over all Black Marias? ( Hawthorne 11 ) . Georgiana? s insouciant attack towards the nevus reveals while she replies? No, so, ? when her hubby asks her? has it ne’er occurred to you [ Georgiana ] that the grade upon your cheek might be removed? ? ( Hawthorne 10 ) . Aylmer nevertheless visions the nevus as Hawthorne says? little blue discolorations which sometimes occur in the purest statuary marble. . . ? ( 11 ) . Later on? Georgiana shortly learn ( s ) to shiver? as her hubby? s hatred towards the nevus considerably additions ( Hawthorne 12 ) . Aylmer? s compulsion shortly starts reflecting in Georgiana. She at this point ignores all warnings and falls quarry to her hubby? s aspiration of taking the nevus, of which, he although is? convinced of the perfect practicableness. . . ? ( Hawthorne 13 ) . Georgiana learns from Aylmer? s dream that, there might be a state of affairs in the class of the operation when he might be? inexorably resolved to cut or twist it [ her bosom ] off? ( Hawthorne 13 ) . Her recent reading of the nevus overshadows this dream as she now even at the? remotest possibility? wants that? the effort be made, at whatever hazard? ( Hawthorne 13 ) . Aylemer? s dream nevertheless is non the lone warning that Georgiana receives. Aylmer to derive assurance in her married woman and to declare success in his new venture performs a twosome of experiments, which consequences futile. Georgiana pays no attentiveness when? the whole works suffer (

s) a blight, its leaves turning coal-black as if by the agency of fire? (Hawthorne 16). Neither did she understand when she finds ?the features of the portrait blurred and indefinable; while the minute figure of the hand appeared where the cheek should have been? (Hawthorne 16). Aylmer?s throwing of the plate into a ?jar of corrosive acid? could well have been a foreshadowing of her fate. Furthermore, while poring over works in her husband?s library, Georgiana loyally ignores the journal those reveal his [Aylmer?s] many failed experiments. The nadir of her [Georgiana?s] self-degradation and worship for her husband shielded her eyes from any logical deductions. Finally Gorgiana consumes the fatal concoction that grips her in its mortal claws. Aylmer prior her death confirms the concoction that Gorgiana mistakes as the ?elixir of life?, to be poisonous (Hawthorne 17). Georgiana shows more concern by Aylmer?s possession of the concoction than her consuming it while saying, ?Why do you keep such a terrific drug?? (Hawthorne 17). She admires her husband even more for not accepting anything other than perfection and: She felt how much more precious was such a sentiment than the meaner kind which would have borne the imperfection for her sake, and have been guilty of treason to holy love by degrading its perfect idea to the level of the actual; and with her whole spirit she prayed that, for a single moment, she might satisfy his highest and deepest conception. (Hawthorne 21) Gorgiana now hates the birthmark even more than Aylmer does in wishing ?to put off this birthmark of mortality by relinquishing mortality itself in preference to any other mode? (Hawthorne 21). Even after realizing that her husband?s concoction has proved fatal; Georgiana shows no sign of repenting but consoles her husband by saying ?you have aimed loftily; you have done nobly. Do not repent that, with so high and pure a feeling, you have rejected the best the earth could offer? (Hawthorne 23). Hawthorne concludes the story by saying, ?he [Aylmer] need not thus have flung away the happiness which would have woven his mortal life of the self-same texture with the celestial? (23). This perhaps can be said for Georgiana too. It can also be said that the fatal concoction damages her heart, and that the birthmark vanishes ?amid the triumphant rush of blood that bathed the whole cheek . . .? (Hawthorne 11). Thus Georgiana would have been wiser resenting her husband?s ambitious intentions of removing ?the visible mark of earthly imperfection? (Hawthorne 11). While her intense love and worship for her husband can never be doubted, her foolish sacrifice, at the same time can not be appreciated.